CPU and Graphics Card Question

[Obsidian 10]

ok here is a quick which one is better question

 

Core2 Quad Q8300 vs i3-3220

and

GTX 650 vs HD7770

[SILVER 10]

depending of the rest of your architecture.....I would go for the i3 of these two

[TheNegotiator 13]

  Obsidian said:

ok here is a quick which one is better question

 

Core2 Quad Q8300 vs i3-3220

and

GTX 650 vs HD7770

 

Using a basic comparison from PassMark Software - CPU Benchmark Charts & PassMark Software - Video Card Benchmark Charts on the surface it would seem that the i3-3220/HD7770 combo is the winner. I would point out though that with the gpu in particular, it depends on whether the card is a reference design from nvidia/amd or it's a partner design. Non-reference usually see a nice boost in performance. But then it depends whether it's needed for the task you want it to perform. If it's for a trading/charting pc, the important thing to check for is really likely to be the number of supported monitors. It looks like the gtx 650 supports upto 4 via dual link dvi and the hd 7770 upto 6 via display port (although using standard connections I think 2 is probably what you'll get for either).

[Obsidian 10]

  TheNegotiator said:

...it would seem that the i3-3220/HD7770 combo is the winner.....

 

I think you are right, I will pick these two

and thanks for the links

[Eddie Z 10]

  Obsidian said:

ok here is a quick which one is better question

 

Core2 Quad Q8300 vs i3-3220

and

GTX 650 vs HD7770

 

The i3-3220 is about 33% faster with a cpu benchmark score of 4300...however, the bear minimum benchmark score you want for trading is 7500! ... This means you need an Intel Core i7....not an i3.....

 

On the videocards the 7770 is marginally better, however both are gaming cards and are overkill for trading....

 

My recommendation is that you spend more on the processor and less on the video cards...

[TheNegotiator 13]

  Eddie Z said:

The i3-3220 is about 33% faster with a cpu benchmark score of 4300...however, the bear minimum benchmark score you want for trading is 7500! ... This means you need an Intel Core i7....not an i3.....

 

On the videocards the 7770 is marginally better, however both are gaming cards and are overkill for trading....

 

My recommendation is that you spend more on the processor and less on the video cards...

 

So this means you shouldn't trade with an i5-3570k or even an i7 920? Sorry Eddie but that's just not true. It depends on what you want. If you have an all-in-one charting/trading platform and have a whole load of different charts and studies open at any one time, then yes the processor is going to take a beating, but even a 2600k or 3770k might struggle. Then if you're going to do backtesting etc. a multi-threaded cpu is likely to be helpful. It's basic comparison with passmark because it's not separating tasks at all. For a specific use, a cpu with a lower score might therefore be more than adequate in performing the tasks required of it. In any case, there's been no mention so far of what the pc is required for!

[Obsidian 10]

hd7770 is for son so it is not trading related

 

have to say that i3 3220 seems very good...i think i7 is not that necessary to run a couple mt4s (previous cpu was e5300)

[davidfry 10]

  SILVER said:

depending of the rest of your architecture.....I would go for the i3 of these two

 

I agree. I3 for sure.

[Eddie Z 10]

4240 i3-3220 benchmark score

3067 Intel Core2 Q8300 benchmark score

 

7500 Minimum benchmark needed for trading

 

Do not purchase either system

 

 

1823 Video benchmark of 650gtx

2144 Video benchmark of 7770

 

Both are actually overkill for trading....but very good for high end gaming