Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Mysticforex

Let's Create a Simple System for Beginners.

Recommended Posts

Even though the Thread says "Beginners", I am starting it in the Forex section because it's what I am most familiar with.

 

I would like participation from beginners and veterans alike. Lets see if we can put together something where a beginner would be able to make a few Pips a week. Let's keep it as simple as possible ( K.I.S.S. ). Let's try to use as few indicators as possible. Let's have a least a 2:1 R/R. We won't discuss position size, or % of return/loss on account ( if the thread is active, these things can come later ).

 

If someone thinks they can improve on it, please make a suggestion.

 

NOTE TO BEGINNERS ! Do not trade these systems. If you think they have potential, then back test them on at least 100 trades. Then forward test them ( DEMO ) on at least 100 trades.

 

Here's my submission. It's a simple breakout called the NY Box. I didn't create it, it's been around for while.

 

 

EUR/USD. 5 min chart. Draw a box over the candles from 6 am to 8 am. Make sure you include the high and the that was reached during that time period. When a candle closes above or below the Box, Trade in that direction. Let's use a 10 pip S/l and a 20 Pip TP.

Todays Box would have looked like this:

nybox.thumb.gif.811ddca508c6d7c263742290b537a1c4.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"If someone thinks they can improve on it, please make a suggestion."

 

try adding guideline number 1

 

"only take positions in the direction of the trend when it enters the box."

 

The trend being subjective - but in my case a visual look at your chart tells me in the example, it was down, so only take shorts if they break below the low of the box.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"If someone thinks they can improve on it, please make a suggestion."

 

try adding guideline number 1

 

"only take positions in the direction of the trend when it enters the box."

 

The trend being subjective - but in my case a visual look at your chart tells me in the example, it was down, so only take shorts if they break below the low of the box.

 

I don't think it will become too complicated if we add 2 MAs, say 200 sma and 50 sma.

Then obviously if the 50 sma is higher than the 200 it is trending up, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This sure looks like a great system! Thanks.

 

I tried out today on the EU. However, if price were to break on the downside, it would hit the 1.33 resistance level and hence the potential for big gain may not be there.

 

After experimenting with a few pairs, I find the GU more viable. But has entered on 50% retracement on a demo a/c as the closing candle that break the box was huge. Nearly hit 20 pips. Unfortunately the price went up after that. Still in the trade, see how it goes....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Far be it for a beginner like me to challenge the wisdom of the masters, but here goes. A way of keeping faith with the KISS concept would be to stringently test any rule proposed to be added, before adding it.

 

Siuya's and Mystic's rule proposes adding a test of trend to the system, being the 50/200 SMA crossover. However, the original system already contains a trend test, implicitly - the 2h box itself. It defines the trend with reference to a breakout beyond the 2h box's High and Low.

 

As today's chart in the above post shows, the box's intrinsic test of trend might be a better test because it is current, rather than looking back too far. Also it is amenable to smaller trend changes, whereas a 200MA has a lot of inertia and will "miss" a lot of a new trend development. Maybe the proposed MAs are too slow for the limited stop-loss / take-profit moves proposed in this system?

 

Hence I propose that the 50/200 MA test remain a "probationary" rule addition at best - to only be added if it can be shown to be better than the simple box trend test.

 

Btw, thanks for starting this thread Mystic. I'm looking forward with much interest to see where it goes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also think we should impose a time limitation. If the trade does not open by XX time, the Box is void and we wait for tomorrows Box....

 

Also, This Friday is NFP. I don't usually trade on NFP days.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I also think we should impose a time limitation. If the trade does not open by XX time, the Box is void and we wait for tomorrows Box....

 

Also, This Friday is NFP. I don't usually trade on NFP days.

 

Also, it's Good Friday, so no real trading going on.

 

I do not want to be a thread spoiler, so I will make one comment and then observe only. This is NOT personal, and nothing against you Mystic, or anyone else contributing.

 

This thread, while well meaning, is the reason so many beginners struggle; I know I did, and while I take responsibility for my own trading, wasting my time with these kinds of ideas is one thing that kept me from improvement when I first started 5 years ago.

 

You come up with an idea -- a logical one, IMO: to trade a breakout of the 2 hour window before the NY market opens. Okay, simple enough, and logical enough.

 

But wait, we have to optimize it. So, we talk about trend. So we add 2 moving averages. No matter that they're crossing all over each other like a DNA helix, just look for which one has the greater value at 8am.

 

But wait, we need to optimize it more. So we add a time limit.

But what if the range is too large (as it is this morning)? Let's limit the size of the "box" to ... And let's say that we will only buy a breakout when the RSI is ...

 

And on, and on, and on, we go. And in the end we have a "system" which has done nothing but taught people how to mindlessly follow rules, and pay no mind to context, current events (FOMC minutes today anyone?), or market sentiment.

 

At least the box idea was simple -- a bit naive mind you, and bound for failure over the long term, but simple.

 

Now, instead of taking a step back and reexamining their approach to the market, people will see this and want to look for similar ideas--similar in what respect? Similar in the respect that they don't learn the instrument they are trading, but rather they learn to draw their box, and wait for the candle to close, and place their order, and pray/hope.

 

And here is the real issue: you could backtest this strategy, and it may have a 65% win rate in the last 12 months, with a great positive expectancy. But you know what? It doesn't matter, because the person following this "system" has not learned to trade. And when this "system" goes ka-put (and it will, they all do over a large sample size), what does the trader do now? Draw the box from 6:30 to 7:30? Try it on another instrument? Consult more forums and ask for people's ideas on more systems?

 

So my contention is that seeking systems, strategies, setups, and the like--they're all an attempt at a shortcut around the inevitable, namely, learning the market one is trying to trade and extract profits from.

 

I won't make any more posts on this thread because I respect your goal and intentions Mystic, but this was my comment and now I'm done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Also, it's Good Friday, so no real trading going on.

 

I do not want to be a thread spoiler, so I will make one comment and then observe only. This is NOT personal, and nothing against you Mystic, or anyone else contributing.

 

This thread, while well meaning, is the reason so many beginners struggle; I know I did, and while I take responsibility for my own trading, wasting my time with these kinds of ideas is one thing that kept me from improvement when I first started 5 years ago.

 

You come up with an idea -- a logical one, IMO: to trade a breakout of the 2 hour window before the NY market opens. Okay, simple enough, and logical enough.

 

But wait, we have to optimize it. So, we talk about trend. So we add 2 moving averages. No matter that they're crossing all over each other like a DNA helix, just look for which one has the greater value at 8am.

 

But wait, we need to optimize it more. So we add a time limit.

But what if the range is too large (as it is this morning)? Let's limit the size of the "box" to ... And let's say that we will only buy a breakout when the RSI is ...

 

And on, and on, and on, we go. And in the end we have a "system" which has done nothing but taught people how to mindlessly follow rules, and pay no mind to context, current events (FOMC minutes today anyone?), or market sentiment.

 

At least the box idea was simple -- a bit naive mind you, and bound for failure over the long term, but simple.

 

Now, instead of taking a step back and reexamining their approach to the market, people will see this and want to look for similar ideas--similar in what respect? Similar in the respect that they don't learn the instrument they are trading, but rather they learn to draw their box, and wait for the candle to close, and place their order, and pray/hope.

 

And here is the real issue: you could backtest this strategy, and it may have a 65% win rate in the last 12 months, with a great positive expectancy. But you know what? It doesn't matter, because the person following this "system" has not learned to trade. And when this "system" goes ka-put (and it will, they all do over a large sample size), what does the trader do now? Draw the box from 6:30 to 7:30? Try it on another instrument? Consult more forums and ask for people's ideas on more systems?

 

So my contention is that seeking systems, strategies, setups, and the like--they're all an attempt at a shortcut around the inevitable, namely, learning the market one is trying to trade and extract profits from.

 

I won't make any more posts on this thread because I respect your goal and intentions Mystic, but this was my comment and now I'm done.

 

Hey, I was wondering, do you have any ideas for what sort of PRICE ACTION a system should use? You know, the sort of PRICE ACTION made for a good SET UP?

 

Just asking

:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Joshdance - I think you are 100% correct - and maybe, just maybe the thread might help this. :)

 

Developing a system using computers is the easy part - optimising it to make a fit a time frame, instrument or type of market is even easier. Using it to trade profitably over a long period of time - not so easy.

 

Learning that a lot of this "might" be a complete waste of time is probably not a waste of time. :2c:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@ Joshdance...

 

Agree with what you are saying. I am not trying to invent something, I don't think I have ever had an original thought in my life ( at least none that I remember ).

I am trying to get people to think, fan an ember maybe.

nybox.thumb.gif.6c00a766d3df3660e1cb62c258afa64c.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tried the method on GU and it earns 20 pips. Done a backtest on a few major pairs that day and it looks promising.

 

Will explore further this NY box.

 

Many thanks, Mysticforex!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi Mysticforex

Why did you pick the time period 6am -8am when the market is flat /low volume.?

Kind regards

bobc

 

Exactly. And we are hoping to see which way the market breaks once NY opens.

Also, in my first post I stated I didn't invent this, it has been around a long time. That is how it has always been done. Maybe a slight variation or tweak here and there.

 

It's just a framework. Let's see where WE can take it. In a week or two, when we have beaten it to death we can move on to something else.

 

This is a Trader's Laboratory, let's experiment.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Exactly. And we are hoping to see which way the market breaks once NY opens.

Also, in my first post I stated I didn't invent this, it has been around a long time. That is how it has always been done. Maybe a slight variation or tweak here and there.

 

It's just a framework. Let's see where WE can take it. In a week or two, when we have beaten it to death we can move on to something else.

 

This is a Trader's Laboratory, let's experiment.

 

Hi Mysticforex

And if the market is flat , there is no trend.And thats an important part of Darvas box trading.Now I dont want to move the time to the open because then we will miss the open.So I will move my box to the last swing high/low.Just before the flat market.This could be during the night session or yesterdays close.I like yesterdays close because of my Taylors TT bias.

As joshdance pointed out, we start out with something simple, and I have made it complicated

regards bobc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a great thread, is there anyone that can test the rules as they are applied to see how they would have done historically?

 

I've got DAX data but no FX data on that time frame.

 

The opening range is not just at the US open, the DAX and the FESX open far earlier. i used to look at the first 30 minutes, some use the first 15 minutes on CL. Once you have the system proven on the US open, you could also test it on the EUR open as well. You test these varied times as well.

 

BTW, we are not optimizing yet....we haven't even tested anything.:roll eyes:

 

In addition to these times, you could consider another opportunity after the lunch break. The market can seem to reconsider the trend during a bite to eat!

 

Also, i would recommend that to start with, as you mentioned...we take profit at 2 x risk. Then we can look at optimizing a stop later.

 

Just a few ideas.

 

Cheers,

 

XS

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This is a great thread, is there anyone that can test the rules as they are applied to see how they would have done historically?

 

I've got DAX data but no FX data on that time frame.

 

The opening range is not just at the US open, the DAX and the FESX open far earlier. i used to look at the first 30 minutes, some use the first 15 minutes on CL. Once you have the system proven on the US open, you could also test it on the EUR open as well. You test these varied times as well.

 

BTW, we are not optimizing yet....we haven't even tested anything.:roll eyes:

 

In addition to these times, you could consider another opportunity after the lunch break. The market can seem to reconsider the trend during a bite to eat!

 

Also, i would recommend that to start with, as you mentioned...we take profit at 2 x risk. Then we can look at optimizing a stop later.

 

Just a few ideas.

 

Cheers,

 

XS

 

 

European traders could do the same and call it the London Box.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • AMZN Amazon stock, nice buying at the 187.26 triple+ support area at https://stockconsultant.com/?AMZN
    • DELL Dell Technologies stock, good day moving higher off the 90.99 double support area, from Stocks to Watch at https://stockconsultant.com/?DELL
    • MCK Mckesson stock, nice trend and continuation breakout at https://stockconsultant.com/?MCK
    • lmfx just officially launched their own LMGX token, Im planning to grab a couple of hundred and maybe have the option to stake them. 
    • Date: 2nd April 2025.   Market on Edge: Tariff Announcement and Volatility Ahead!   The US economic and employment data continues to deteriorate with the job vacancies figures dropping to a 5-month low. In addition to this, the IMS Manufacturing PMI also fell below expectations. However, both the US Dollar and Gold declined simultaneously following the release of the two figures, an uncommon occurrence in the market. Traders expect a key factor to be today’s ‘liberation day’ where the US will impose tariffs on imports. USDJPY - Traders Await Tariff Confirmation! Traders looking to determine how the USDJPY will look today will find it difficult to determine until the US confirms its tariff plan. Today is the day when Trump previously stated he would finalize and announce his tariff plan. The administration has not yet released the policy, but investors expect it to be the most expansionary in a century. President Trump is due to speak at 20:00 GMT. On HFM's Calendar the speech is stated as "US Liberation Day Tariff Announcement". Currently, analysts are expecting Trump’s Tariff Plan to impose tariffs on the EU, chips and pharmaceuticals later today as well as reciprocal tariffs. Economists have a good idea of how these tariffs may take effect, but reciprocal tariffs are still unspecified. In addition to this, 25% tariffs on the car industry will start tomorrow. The tariffs on the foreign cars industry are a factor which will particularly impact Japan. Although, traders should note that this is what is expected and is not yet finalised. Last week, President Trump stated that he would implement retaliatory tariffs but allow exemptions for certain US trade partners. Treasury Secretary Mr Bessent and National Economic Council Director Mr Hassett suggested that the restrictions would primarily target 15 countries responsible for the bulk of the US trade deficit. However, yesterday, Trump contradicted these statements, asserting that additional duties would be imposed on any country that has implemented similar measures against US products. The day’s volatility will depend on which route the US administration takes. The harshness of the policy will influence both the Japanese Yen as well as the US Dollar.   USDJPY 5-Minute Chart   US Economic and Employment Data The JOLT Job Vacancies figure fell below expectations and is lower than the previous month’s figure. The JOLT Job Vacancies read 7.57 million whereas the average of the past 6 months is 7.78 million. The ISM Manufacturing Index also fell below the key level of 50.00 and was 5 points lower than what analysts were expecting. The data is negative for the US Dollar, particularly as the latest release applies more pressure on the Federal Reserve to cut interest rates. However, this is unlikely to happen if the trade policy ignites higher and stickier inflation. In the Bank of Japan’s Governor's latest speech, Mr Ueda said that the tariffs are likely to trigger higher inflation. USDJPY Technical Analysis Currently, the Japanese Yen Index is the worst performing of the day while the US Dollar Index is more or less unchanged. However, this is something traders will continue to monitor as the EU session starts. In the 2-hour timeframe, the USDJPY is trading at the neutral level below the 75-bar EMA and 100-bar SMA. The RSI and MACD is also at the neutral level meaning traders should be open to price movements in either direction. On the smaller timeframes, such as the 5-minute timeframe, there is a slight bias towards a bullish outcome. However, this is only likely if the latest bearish swing does not drop below the 200-Bar SMA.     The key resistant level can be seen at 150.262 and the support level at 149.115. Breakout levels are at 149.988 and 149.674. Key Takeaway Points: Job vacancies hit a five-month low, and the ISM Manufacturing PMI missed expectations, adding pressure on the Federal Reserve regarding interest rate decisions. Traders await confirmation on Trump’s tariff policy, which is expected to impact the EU, chips, pharmaceuticals, and foreign car industries. The severity of the tariffs will influence both the JPY and the USD, with traders waiting for final policy details. The Japanese Yen Index is the worst index of the day while the US Dollar Index is unchanged. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news.   Michalis Efthymiou HFMarkets   Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.