Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Soultrader

Discretionary Trading vs Automated Trading

Recommended Posts

why is it that the majority of successful intraday traders are discretionary traders?
Becuase they are skilled in reading the markets and not necessarly skilled in codifying what it is they're doing when they analyze the markets. Most would not even know what they are doing on a conscious level.

 

To break down and model what somebody else does is tough enough. To do it for yourself on yourself, while you're doing it is almost impossible.

 

There seem to be two distinct camps: Those than can trade and those that can write great code that doesn't trade well. The two cannot communicate effectively.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone here trade fully automated? Or have you tried to trade fully automated in the past?

 

What kind of issue did you face?

 

Any day trading system traders here? What kind of commission do you pay? How many trades do you make a day? Whats the slippage on each trade?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
In reply to syswizard: "emotional and psychological aspects of market behavior" are presumably reflected in the charts and tape or how else would a discretionary trader see them? So if they're reflected in the charts and the tape then they could be automated. And yes it is possible to analyse and interpret news events. In fact it's extremely simple to code an Excel macro that enters an order on the basis of an economic data release (released real time by Bloomberg and Reuters). Reuters, Bloomberg and Dow Jones also use XML tags that enable automated systems to react instantaneously to news events. Why do you think the market reaction to news events is instantaneous? Because automated systems are reacting within milliseconds - much faster than any discretionary trader could react.

Being FAST doesn't correlate to being CORRECT.

re: "...are presumably reflected in the charts and tape"...

sorry, I totally disagree.....the reflection doesn't appear till AFTER THE FACT.

Same situation is seen in professional poker....the instincts and intuition of the best players is simply amazing.....and not easily "programmed". They are acting upon the NEXT CARD, not what is currently "showing" ie the "charts".

re: "excel macro to enter orders"....oh yeah, any DUFUS can now easily enter automated orders thanks to IB's work in simplifying the ever-so-awful FIX interface. And with this, I've seen so many traders crash-and-burn especially when trading the financial index futures.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Brownsfan: you could be as flexible in coding an automated system as you are in implementing a discretionary system. What are you looking for in interpreting your candles? For price to swiftly reverse on high volume? That can be coded into an automated system.

 

Notouch - I am not looking to code that at all. I don't believe I posted that the way I trade candles is to look for high volume on a price reversal anywhere on this site. So, perhaps what you posted can be automated, but that's not how I trade at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Notouch - I am not looking to code that at all. I don't believe I posted that the way I trade candles is to look for high volume on a price reversal anywhere on this site. So, perhaps what you posted can be automated, but that's not how I trade at all.

 

It was just a hypothetical question. :p

 

The point is that to be a successful trader you have to follow rules and any rule-based system can be automated. Your rules can be as strict or flexible as you like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It was just a hypothetical question. :p

 

The point is that to be a successful trader you have to follow rules and any rule-based system can be automated. Your rules can be as strict or flexible as you like.

 

Well thats the tricky part. Discretionary traders may not have rules for each trade they take. Alot of discretionary trading is based on "gut" feel just like a poker player will be able to read the opponents hand through player psychology and probabilities. Do not mistaken this with impulsive trading. Discretionary trading involves good judgement and intuition. As TheBramble pointed out "Most would not even know what they are doing on a conscious level." This is why discretionary trading can not be automated 100%.

 

Ive pointed this Linda Raschke quote before somewhere else:

 

"I've known hundreds of professional traders throughout my career. I don't want to disappoint you, but I know of only two who were able to make a steady living for themselves with a mechanical system.â€Â

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure trading on the basis of a gut feeling is going to give you an edge. I think sticking to your rules will give you the edge. I am open to the idea that the human mind is like a neural network that can be programmed to spot complex patterns but I doubt there are many people who could successfully trade that way.

 

I'm sure Linda Raschke was thinking of canned systems like MA crossover systems when she spoke of mechanical systems. I doubt she was thinking of advanced black box systems run by investment banks. I'll try to find the article I read somewhere saying that there'll be 90% fewer traders in London within the next few decades - replaced by programmers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Ive pointed this Linda Raschke quote before somewhere else:

 

"I've known hundreds of professional traders throughout my career. I don't want to disappoint you, but I know of only two who were able to make a steady living for themselves with a mechanical system.â€Â

 

I guess that might be true for traders who use a mechanical system that is static and doesnt develop. If someone invested sufficient time into programming so that they could modify the programs they use to suit changing market conditions this might not hold true in the long term. But then again to be that good at programming you really need to spend a long time learning it. The opportunity cost is learning the markets urself as a discretionary trader!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not trading automated but I'm studying a lot about it. The seach for the holy Grail.... well dreams are free :P

First of all I think I need to trade by myself and if that succeed (ie. not losing money) then and only then I should be able to develop a semi-automated trading system.

 

However I stumpled across this website: Collective2 - The Trading System Authority which compares a lot of different automated trading systems. I've found this one: Collective2: woowy 2007/3 especially interesting ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Collective2 is an interesting website. I ran a couple test systems there and it's a great exercise if you really want to see how you perform in real time. The only issue I had was that if you need to execute orders quickly, there was a serious lag at times b/c it is a web based order entry system.

 

I would suggest taking a look if you want to test some ideas out and/or make a few extra bucks from people subscribing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Look, unless you're a Quant doing it for salary, and don't need to show consistently profitable results in all market conditions - forget it. There's little point.

 

Read "Trading Systems"; Joe Krutsinger and find out how those who are supposed to be guru system developers for trading systems do it. There are hundreds of systems they use and have used. What does this tell you? There isn't one system they've automated or codified which does the job. OK?

 

Most of the systems they use are based on MAs and BOs. Really simple, basic stuff. Which work real well. Manually. You don't need a system. If you're too lazy to do your research and run your analyses yourself then you deserve all the success you're unlikely to get. Trading is not a get rich quick and stay rich endeavour. You get what you put in.

 

If you want a plug-n-play approach to trading, use a mutual fund.

 

If you think you can program a better solution to your current trading than your current trading - you can't. Trust me. If you were than good you'd be inventing the next Microsoft.

 

You're either a Trader or a Programmer.

 

If you're a Trader, take the time and make the effort to Trade!!! And do it perfectly.

 

If you're a Programer, take the time and make the effort to Program!!! And do it perfectly.

 

Both endeavours are equally gifted and equally appreciated. But confusing the two leads to not much at all really.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I work as a systemdeveloper for a living and I don't think it's possible to program a piece of SW that can do better than an experienced trader. However I've a strong believe that a program can do scan through a list of stocks and filter out the most potential ones. For instance, give me all stocks which is accumulating along with a growing momentum or scan for stocks with ma(50)day is crossing ma(200)day from above or.... but to create the Holy Grail huh... imho impossible, however I do think that a nice implemented trading system can perform alot better than the average trader.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For instance, give me all stocks which is accumulating...
:) Well actually, you can do this even with the most basic of scanners.

 

What constitutes accumulation? What factors lead YOU to belive a stock is being accumulated? And it's not OK to simply say 'a stock which doesn't appear on anyone else's scanner' as that is a very circular argument.

 

What tells you a stock is being accumulated as opposed to simply being ignored? How do you know?

 

I'll give you a cluse - it's CONTEXT.

 

I'll see if I can figure a way to put this in non-trading terms as it sometimes helps to get a fix from non-trading bearings when we discuss the deeper apsects of what goes on in reality.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Look, unless you're a Quant doing it for salary, and don't need to show consistently profitable results in all market conditions - forget it. There's little point.

 

Read "Trading Systems"; Joe Krutsinger and find out how those who are supposed to be guru system developers for trading systems do it. There are hundreds of systems they use and have used. What does this tell you? There isn't one system they've automated or codified which does the job. OK?

 

Most of the systems they use are based on MAs and BOs. Really simple, basic stuff. Which work real well. Manually. You don't need a system. If you're too lazy to do your research and run your analyses yourself then you deserve all the success you're unlikely to get. Trading is not a get rich quick and stay rich endeavour. You get what you put in.

 

If you want a plug-n-play approach to trading, use a mutual fund.

 

If you think you can program a better solution to your current trading than your current trading - you can't. Trust me. If you were than good you'd be inventing the next Microsoft.

 

You're either a Trader or a Programmer.

 

If you're a Trader, take the time and make the effort to Trade!!! And do it perfectly.

 

If you're a Programer, take the time and make the effort to Program!!! And do it perfectly.

 

 

I have to disagree with you there. I come from the exact opposite side of everything you are assuming above.

 

I do trade fully automated models. I do code professionally for myself. So for those of you out there that dream of automated trading, it is possible, BUT it comes at a great price.

 

Joe Krutsinger and the gurus that sell stuff, don't trade for a living, and never made a dime trading. So I agree with you on that, they are not examples to follow or even consider. All their work is useless to me. There is so much more valuable knowledge that is priceless published for free in academic circles, I dont think you need to spend a dime on courses etc.

 

Possibly the best public model EVER is Mark Brown's OddBall system which was published a few years back. Some of the largest hedge fund and bank traders are keying off of OddBall or some variation of OddBall. I know this for a fact and I have seen thousands of contracts pure into the pit and globex when Oddball fires of its signals.

 

This is proof that it is possible to create your own systems and trading models, however having siad that I did hear that Mark Brown used cray computers to create and find these models.

 

I personally still use a variation of OddDball to this day after about 5 years of it being published. Track record is solid and anyone with some basic prog knowledge can get it running!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Horus, very encouraging and true that systems do work. It's a matter of skills, creativity and lots of sweats that you'll eventually get a decent system that earns something.

 

Back to Oddball, wouldn't this system become obsolete because everyone is trading at the same time and eventually cancel themselves out? Eventually the market will absorb and change to make the system becoming useless. I'm speaking of too many using the same system, not systems in general as useless.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi torero... exactly my thoughts also. I've found this: NeoTicker Blog » Oddball System - An Update it's clear that the system performed very bad after 2002.

Could that be the evidence that it has been over used?

 

Horus -> You mentioned you're using a slightly improved variation of OddBall, do you mind to share - not the exact algorithm, but just some bits?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What constitutes accumulation? What factors lead YOU to belive a stock is being accumulated? And it's not OK to simply say 'a stock which doesn't appear on anyone else's scanner' as that is a very circular argument.

 

If the stock accumulates or distributes you can tell it by looking at A/D - Accumulation/Distribution Technical Indicators, Technical Analysis

 

So back to my point, the scanner could then look for long entries by filtering what stocks that have a growth rate greater then 3% taken from bottom reversal, furthermore it could use some sort of a regressionline between two earlier top or bottoms to enhance the probability....

 

All this is only pure guess work, but it's something that I'm going to test as time goes by :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many many system failed after the 2002 because they were best during the tech bubble but after that volatility changed. Systems need to be improved or optimized from time to time (when is the million $ question). No system will last forever, they will work at one time or another, like discretionary traders, even they go into drawdowns from time to time, even the best and experienced happen to them.

 

The fact that so many systems are trading the same way eventually they get diluted, new systems will come and take advantage of them and make them obsolete. It's like everything, empires will come and go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Neoticker implementation of OddBall is incorrect. They missed the timing issue which is one of the key factors in OddBall. I had no problem in 2002, the returns were less but the system made money at the end of the year. The core concept behind oddball is unbreakable because its absolute market truth.

 

Its funny from one stand point discretionary traders always say the reason their methods like retracement, Fibonacci and pivots work is due to self fulfilling prophecy, if enough people follow it, a support level will hold!

 

Then on the other hand, when discretionary traders talk about system, they tell you, it failed because too many people are following it! The fact is no one knows and if the core concept is solid, its very hard to break a system. SO the reason systems and methodologies fail is not because "too many" followers, rather its core concept is only a fad. Its a patterns observed which has nothing to do with the core dynamics of markets.

 

As for variations of Oddball, just do your own research and it will be fruitful. The core concept is unique and solid. There are hundreds of variations possible some good, some great! It does take a lot of sweat to make something you are comfortable with trading. The keys to any method is the creator first then the concept. I can give a model and I GUARANTEE you out of 100 people only 2 can match my results in REAL LIFE. Turtles are system traders, at least start that way, now run empires in money management.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have to disagree with you there. I come from the exact opposite side of everything you are assuming above.

 

I do trade fully automated models. I do code professionally for myself. So for those of you out there that dream of automated trading, it is possible, BUT it comes at a great price.

 

Joe Krutsinger and the gurus that sell stuff, don't trade for a living, and never made a dime trading. So I agree with you on that, they are not examples to follow or even consider. All their work is useless to me. There is so much more valuable knowledge that is priceless published for free in academic circles, I dont think you need to spend a dime on courses etc.

 

Possibly the best public model EVER is Mark Brown's OddBall system which was published a few years back. Some of the largest hedge fund and bank traders are keying off of OddBall or some variation of OddBall. I know this for a fact and I have seen thousands of contracts pure into the pit and globex when Oddball fires of its signals.

 

This is proof that it is possible to create your own systems and trading models, however having siad that I did hear that Mark Brown used cray computers to create and find these models.

 

I personally still use a variation of OddDball to this day after about 5 years of it being published. Track record is solid and anyone with some basic prog knowledge can get it running!

Then I stand corrected. You are a trader and a system developer that makes consistent profits (more than 5 years) using an automated trading system they have devised and written themselves, but you are the only one, maybe just the first of that breed I have never before encountered.

 

I came from a technical programming background (many years ago) and initially thought there was a direct link between sexy code and great trading. The thing is, even when you finally get to consistent trading results, you realize (sorry, I realized) that the process I used was (a) too simple to require automating and (b) too complex to automate because of all the little discretionary aspects of it which I hadn't realized existed before I tried to codify what it is precisely that I do.

 

The effort to produce and mantain any system for me was WAY too expensive in time and effort and it also diminished that aspect of trading that I enjoyed the most - actually trading!

 

I am pleased to have found someone though who seems to have successfully combined the two disciplines and I can update my world model accordingly.

 

I'll check out Oddball as you give it a recommendaton.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If the stock accumulates or distributes you can tell it by looking at A/D - Accumulation/Distribution  Technical Indicators, Technical Analysis

 

So back to my point, the scanner could then look for long entries by filtering what stocks that have a growth rate greater then 3% taken from bottom reversal, furthermore it could use some sort of a regressionline between two earlier top or bottoms to enhance the probability....

 

All this is only pure guess work, but it's something that I'm going to test as time goes by :)

januson, throwing a textbook definition at the topic doesn't really help. The A/D you relate is flawed, it's validity is based upon either a trending instrument or on a divergence with price. Neither work.

 

I was talking about the deeper market forces, strong hands, big money actions to quiety acquire large blocks of stocks without impacting th eprice and the same divesting themselves of these stocks to their advantage.

 

Accumulation of this nature does not appear as big volume (the major weighting factor of the A/D). The divestment occurs generally in the public participation part of the bull run (the blowoff) and required somewhat less finesse to operate or identify.

 

For our purposes, looking at this from a more professional manner rather than the textbook manner that most newbies, including myself when I was going through the learning curve, will require slightly different thinking.

 

My initial question was: What do we need to know about a stock's price and volume profile to assess whether it is simply being ignored or is being quiety accumulated.

 

Your suggestion of 'growth rate greater than 3%' is possibly going to find those stocks which are in or starting a trend. Possibly. And that's fine, but I didn't think we were discussing the process at that level.

 

I'll bow out if I've misunderstood what it was I thought you were attempting to discuss.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • PLTR Palantir Technologies stock watch, consolidation at the 81.29 triple support area at https://stockconsultant.com/?PLTR
    • WMT Walmart stock watch, big pullback to 84.84 support area with high trade quality at https://stockconsultant.com/?WMT
    • AXSM Axsome Therapeutics stock watch. pullback to 120.5 gap support area with bullish indicators at https://stockconsultant.com/?AXSM
    • Date: 14th March 2025.   Gold Surges Past Record High as Market Volatility Persists.     Gold Surges Past Record High as Market Volatility Persists Gold surged towards $2,994 per ounce, surpassing its previous high set on Thursday. With a 2.6% rise this week, gold is on track for its most significant gain since November. Meanwhile, gold futures in New York comfortably exceeded the $3,000 mark, reflecting strong investor sentiment toward the precious metal. The robust performance of gold this quarter extends its strong annual rally in 2024. Market uncertainty, exacerbated by the US administration’s aggressive trade policies, has dampened risk appetite for equities, pushing the S&P 500 into correction territory this week. Central bank purchases increased ETF inflows, and bullish forecasts from major banks have further fueled gold’s ascent. Trade Tensions and Market Impact Former President Donald Trump escalated trade tensions by proposing a 200% tariff on European alcoholic beverages, including wine and champagne. Additionally, he reaffirmed his stance on retaining tariffs on steel and aluminium and signalled that reciprocal tariffs on global trade partners could take effect as early as April 2. As we approach the second quarter, reciprocal tariffs could drive another wave of market turbulence, solidifying gold’s appeal as a safe-haven asset. Gold and Equity Market Reactions The upward momentum in gold has also lifted mining stocks, with Australia’s Evolution Mining Ltd. reaching an all-time high. Global holdings in gold-backed ETFs increased to 2,687 tons, marking the highest level since November 2023. Analysts at major banks remain bullish on gold’s trajectory. Macquarie Group recently forecasted a potential spike to $3,500 per ounce in Q2, while BNP Paribas revised its outlook to show gold prices consistently above $3,000. Gold traded at $2,983.50 per ounce in the Asia session, reflecting a 14% year-to-date gain. Meanwhile, silver edged lower after nearing $34 per ounce, while platinum and palladium recorded gains.     US Stock Market Recovery Amid Uncertainty After a sharp sell-off, US stock futures rebounded. Futures tied to the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 0.4%, while S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite futures gained 0.6% and 0.8%, respectively. Despite the slight recovery, Wall Street remains on edge following the S&P 500’s descent into correction territory. Trump’s firm stance on tariffs has added to market concerns. During a meeting with NATO’s secretary general, he dismissed any possibility of easing trade restrictions, acknowledging that further market disruptions may lie ahead. Government Shutdown and Economic Indicators Adding to the economic uncertainty, a potential US government shutdown loomed over Wall Street. However, a breakthrough emerged late Thursday as Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer signalled a willingness to advance a Republican-led stopgap spending bill. Today the University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment survey is expected to shed light on how consumers are coping with inflation and trade disruptions. Last month’s report indicated weakening economic confidence, which could have further implications for spending trends. Asian Markets Rally Amid China’s Economic Stimulus Asian stock markets saw a strong performance this morning, brushing off Wall Street’s losses. Chinese stocks surged after state-run banks and financial institutions were instructed to support consumer spending. Hong Kong’s Hang Seng Index jumped 2.5% to 24,038.85, while the Shanghai Composite Index gained 1.9% to 3,420.65. In Tokyo, the Nikkei 225 added 0.9%, while Australia’s ASX 200 climbed 0.6%. China’s National Financial Regulatory Administration issued directives aimed at boosting consumer finance, including encouraging credit card usage and providing support for struggling borrowers. Economists, however, argue that broader reforms—such as wage growth and enhanced social welfare—are necessary for sustained economic recovery. Wall Street’s Struggles Amid AI Stock Declines Despite positive economic data, including lower-than-expected wholesale inflation and strong job market indicators, stock market turbulence continued. AI-related stocks, which have been at the forefront of market gains, faced renewed pressure. Palantir Technologies fell 4.8%, Super Micro Computer dropped 8%, and Nvidia fluctuated before closing 0.1% lower. Tesla also struggled, declining 3% and extending its 2025 losses to over 40%. In contrast, Intel shares soared 14.6% after announcing Lip-Bu Tan as its new CEO. Oil Prices and Currency Movements In commodities, US crude oil prices rose by $0.46 to $67.01 per barrel, while Brent crude increased by $0.44 to $70.32 per barrel. The US dollar strengthened to 148.63 Yen, while the Euro dipped slightly to $1.0845. Conclusion Market volatility remains high as investors navigate shifting trade policies, inflation concerns, and economic uncertainties. While gold continues to shine as a safe-haven asset, equity markets face persistent headwinds. As geopolitical and economic developments unfold, traders and investors must remain vigilant in the days ahead.   Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news.   Andria Pichidi HFMarkets   Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • ItuGlobal: Our Latest NETELLER VIPs 2025 ITU GLOBAL VIP Members’ Rewards Every calendar year, we choose 2 customers to become our VIPs. They’ve permanently special status with us and they can fund/withdraw Neteller through us, at parallel market rates, whether they open brokerage accounts through us or not.   These are people who funded with the highest amount of Neteller, and who also withdrew the highest amount of Neteller through us.  They would be announced in January each year and added to our list of VIPs. ItuGlobal: Our Latest NETELLER VIPs 2025 Adetoye Oyebanji Babalola: Adetoye O. has started selling large quantities of Neteller to us since the very beginning of our company’s existence. He also sold Perfect Money to us many times, when PM was still available in Nigeria. Besides, he has given us a lot of helpful business advice, which has proven to be invaluable to us. He deserves to become our VIP. Isiaka Adekunle Mohammed: He is a constant buyer. Buying e-currencies and also funding his Instaforex account through us. We thank Isiaka A. for his trust in us and wish him the best in everything he does. Abiodun Lawanson: This is an avid buyer and seller of Neteller. He buys and makes profits and sells back to us. Sometimes when we are not online, he will send an offline message and we will process his order once we come back online. He has thus become our VIP. Source: Ituglobalfx.com.ng  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.