Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Soultrader

Discretionary Trading vs Automated Trading

Recommended Posts

You rarely sell at the ask or buy at the bid. Certainly nothing you can depend on. This has to be taken into account when programming. Tradestation/Easy Language does not take this into account, you need to program it yourself. Tradestations ProftTarget strategy will fill limit orders on a touch which is not realistic at all.

I disagree here....for one, e-mini futures fills with limit orders (buy@bid,sell@ask) have been filled about 80% of the time. However, my experience with Nasdaq stocks was about the opposite.

For another, one thing to do is to backtest with the Limit orders, and then in real live trading, make them MIT orders.....most platforms are supporting those now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

80% of the time pretty much screws the reliability of the backtest results wouldn't you say? You want to test as close to 100% real world environment as possible. Those 20% could well mean all the winning trades that never happen. IMO I wouldn't even continue testing if I cannot find a 99% of the results resembling live trading.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
With the advancement in technology and improvements in trading softwares, many intraday traders are now automating their trading. There are advantages to this... emotions can be eliminated (not completely but more than discretionary) and traders can use mechanical exit points. Example: scaling out at +10pts on every trade.

 

As a pure discretionary trader, I still believe there is an edge in discretionary trading. Intuition comes into play as well as better entries. Why better entries? If one is a good tape reader he can pinpoint his entries and take minimal heat. This can save a trader a ton of points in the long run.

 

I have a couple questions regarding this topic and could use your guys opinion. Do you think discretionary traders enter before automated traders? What are your thoughts on discretionary vs automation? What type of trader are you and which one do you prefer?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Soultrader, I'm relatively new to trading (less than a year). I have made a decision to be a discretionary trader. I trade forex, using only price, candlesticks, support and resistance. Looking for breakouts of channels, consolidations and trendlines on longer term charts, then taking the signal in same direction on an hourly chart. More or less this is my style of trading so far.

 

I read everywhere that backtesting is essential to succeed. As I mostly trade off price patterns, how can I backtest? If I can't backtest how can I put together statistics like, percentage winners, losers, drawdown etc.

 

Any answers greatly appreciated.

 

Thanks,

 

Soultrader

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not Soultrader but I will explain this thanks to Jason Alan Jankovsky's book.

 

Volume is what drives prices higher or lower. Volume is caused by some other trader who is either getting into or out of a trade.

 

Spot FX being an unregulated market does not have a centralized exchange to post volume. eSignal provides volume to their FX data.

 

Price patterns alone do not tell the full story, what you need to be aware of is the volume in relation to the price pattern to get a higher probabiltiy of one thing happening more than the other.

 

I have tried trading FX just off price patterns because "thats all the FX market has to look at." Lets just say I am not a big fan of the FX market, not because I cannot trade it but rather the lack of infomation.

 

I have found that understanding trading psychology and behavior yields much greater results than relying on technical patterns and indicators to decide what course of action or inaction to take.

 

The way to see that behaviour is through the analysis of just price and volume.

 

There is alway some discretion to your trading, you still need to decide to take the trade or not when you think about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Soultrader, I'm relatively new to trading (less than a year). I have made a decision to be a discretionary trader. I trade forex, using only price, candlesticks, support and resistance. Looking for breakouts of channels, consolidations and trendlines on longer term charts, then taking the signal in same direction on an hourly chart. More or less this is my style of trading so far.

 

I read everywhere that backtesting is essential to succeed. As I mostly trade off price patterns, how can I backtest? If I can't backtest how can I put together statistics like, percentage winners, losers, drawdown etc.

 

Any answers greatly appreciated.

 

Thanks,

 

Soultrader

 

Hi DrEvil,

 

I trade discretionary but I have rules for each trading setup. I dont use a backtesting software though. What I do is keep track of each setup on a spreadsheet everyday and keep up with the data. If I see some setups failing to work after a while, I will observe it and see how I can improve it. It would be pretty much impossible to backtest most of my setups as I rely heavily on internals and tape. I also like to think in terms of market concept such as asking Why or What.

 

Soultrader

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the the answers guys. I'n my limited experience I find that on daily forex charts, a combination of classic price patterns and candlesticks are quite reliable. The problems I have are mainly trying to day trade by using hourly charts after receiving a signal on a daily chart ... the patterns certainly don't behave as well intraday. I am not at this point trading big enough to trade off daily charts. I find that I get a lot of information from looking at daily closing prices, which I assume filters out the day trading noise. For example if I can get a breakout of an congestion area on a daily chart, confirmed by a close on the daily bar, then I will always take a hourly trading on ideally a flag or pullback to a trend line, or m.a.

 

I agree that lack of volume info is a handicap, but isn't it a handicap for everyone? ... thus leveling the playing field?

 

I wasted months trying to figure out indicators and since I have removed them and focussed on price, I think I have raised my game. I hope I am on the right path.

 

Good trading!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The problems I have are mainly trying to day trade by using hourly charts after receiving a signal on a daily chart ... the patterns certainly don't behave as well intraday.

 

I find that I get a lot of information from looking at daily closing prices, which I assume filters out the day trading noise.

 

I agree that lack of volume info is a handicap, but isn't it a handicap for everyone? ... thus leveling the playing field?

 

I wasted months trying to figure out indicators and since I have removed them and focussed on price, I think I have raised my game. I hope I am on the right path.

 

Good trading!

 

You're helping (analyzing) yourself already and you don't even know it.

 

Day trading may not suit your personality. Don't force a style of trading onto yourself if it is not working. If you lose money, stop doing it. Remember what I said before, "in order to make money, you need to stop losing money" or somewhere along those lines. How you come to terms of stopping the "harmful" actions is up to you, but that is the key to being a net winning trader.

 

Level playing fields in FX, I think not, there are some who do get FX volume, you can spot where the "big money" is coming into the market to take your money. All volume does is confirm if there are players or not because if you get more volume in your direction, you have a pretty good chance your trade will work out. It's not a shoe in, but you will have the edge.

 

I am so glad to here you junked the technical indicators that are mathematical based. You definately are on the right path.

 

Just remember you will not succeed at this game if you quit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think there is never level playing in every market you trade in, i.e. the locals will almost always be one step ahead of you, the market makers will always be one step ahead of you. Given, that forex is the same way. Volume is important but somehow I've managed to stay profitable without volume. One change or adaptation I've made from futures to forex is I scrutinize price action more, be more picky with S/R areas and relied on Fibs, Pivots more to really make sure the setup is overwhelmingly in my favor. Basically I made sure the breakout is TRULY confirmed before making that entry and stay away from ranges, trend-following specifically. All this without volume, a miracle in some ways. The other observation I've made is that my R/R ratio is high 3:1 minimum or I don't trade. Surprisingly this is what has made the equity curve climb. I've managed to get many 3:1 wins when it was a winning trade.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm about to embark on implementing a semi-automated way of trading for myself. Basically, I need things to be as mechanized as I can make it, or else I may not take certain trades. My trades will all be based on Market Profile, and I'll basically just make my calls pre market, and setup my working orders so they're out there to get filled, and the odds are in my favor that the market will do as I plan on. Based on my analysis of the market I trade over the past while, the setups are pretty well defined. When the first setup fails and I lose some points, then I know right where the next setup will be to get that lost profit back and then some.

 

That's basically how I will be doing it for this entire week, and if it works in my favor, then I'll be doing that from here on out. I'm basically posting it up here so I have some accountability and know I need to follow through with it, instead of sayin...ah, nevermind. I can go purely discretionary since it's not making me much money, and thats what I love, right? not making money? ummmm, nope. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I would assume that most discretionary traders are such because they either a: dont know how to code and b: they love to have the "hands on" approach to their trading.

 

If you love to trade why would you take away the enjoyment of it through using an automated system?

 

Soultrader asked before what would become of discretinary traders as more and more ppl become reliant on automatic systems. Well I may not be a coding genius (i dont know diddly by the way) but i would assume that these systems are all reactinary in nature i.e. they react to what the market does. I wouldn't think an automated system could ever make the market move! If everything was automated 100%, where would the momentum in a market come from?

 

I migth be wrong about my analysis of automated sytems but in the end I think that yes there are still more discretinary traders and these people are the real market makers.

 

If you love to trade, and love the wheeling and dealings of the markets why would you contemplate giving that up in the first place?

 

Good luck on your trading mates!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read somewhere that most of the liquidity on the NYSE comes from automated systems and the percentage is growing on Globex and Eurex. That doesn't mean the market will be untradeable for discretionary traders although the nature of the market will change as it always does.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

really? Where did u see that?

 

I must not be able to understand how these automated systems work to well, cause I can only conceptualise them as bein 100% reactionary to what the prices are doing. In a market with low volume and price basically flat how would an automated system get the ball rolling?

 

If these systems are profitable in the long run, it's pretty interesting and I'd like to learn more about how one would go about setting one up especially if one is coding illiterate!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another pertinent question that could be asked would be: Is automated trading likely to overtake discretionary trading in the future or make it obsolete?

 

Personally I can't see that hapenning. Very "terminator" to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sounds like some of you are looking for the holy grail of trading again. I'd love to have a box (software) that you just turn the crank and out comes the cash but it hasn't happened yet and I don't think it's going to. The markets change to much. What moves it today isn't going to do it in the same amount and the same way tomorrow. All I see in this magic software is another level of work and confusion. Instead of using our human brain for basic primary decisions I see it being used for making decisions of factors that may or may not make a difference, and those factors my change from plus or minus and in varying degrees. Gosh, I can programs to make programs just to establish values to put into trading software. The market is the market because of the human nature, when you can plug in all 8 billion people and their thinking at the time automated systems might have a chance. All this said, if anyone has one that works and will always work, let me know! I'd love to go drink beer and know the old computer is cranking out cash. Right now I'd settle for a program that would automatically do my taxes, use creative credits and deductions, print out receipts for them and guarantee I'd stay out of trouble with the IRS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nick1984, every system is 100% reactionary - you always react to something, otherwise it is random. Not all automated systems are price-based. Reuters (an I expect other institutional data providers) already feed their clients with fundamental data in an "algorithm-friendly" form. So automated systems can process reports generated by FED and other agencies. Goldman-Sachs is throwing out 60+ traders and replacing them by automated systems. What else is necesary to say?

 

Personally, I am both automated system trader and discretionary. Both, if done right and after spending enormous amount of effort can be profitable. Single whatever great automated system is always less profitable than good discretionary trader due to timing (and I do not accept the graph posted here because the guy was fooling himself by buying at bid, selling at ask, if not mentioning slippage). On the other side, you can auto-trade several systems at one and fully utilize kelly ratio which discretionary trader cannot. In the end you end up with similar results. No way is easier or better than the other, it is about what suits you more.

 

Nelo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
How would one go about programming tape reading? Pretty impossible I'd say.

Penn-Lehman SOBI ATS project

Never say never.....the big brokers are into this stuff in a huge way (have you seen their earnings recently ?)

The smart kids at Penn/Wharton came-up with a pretty novel approach to reading the order book and this strategy (after modifications of course) eventually went live at Lehman Brothers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting thread...

 

As I mentioned in another post, I suppose I am a discretionary automated trader... In other words, I am discretionary b/c I am pulling the trigger myself and automated b/c I simply follow my rules.

 

In my time as a trader and broker, I have never seen a successful automated system that can stand the test of time. I won't argue that some systems are very profitable in a given period of time (but who's system can't do that, right?). The key in my opinion for the automated traders is knowing when to turn your system 'off' or when to leave it alone. It's easy in hindsight to say that based on your backtesting, you would have turned it off at XYZ point, but making that call in real time is not so easy. If you turn it off and you simply were in a small drawdown, you lose. If you let it run and turn your account into half in one month (like the blog post pasted here), you lose. And as that blog post said, in essence, no matter what - your emotions can/will drive your ultimate decisions even if you are a 'hands off automated' trader.

 

And of course the devil's advocate in me says that if there are successful automated traders out there, you won't find them on the internet message boards. I think they in fact have too much to lose by even hinting to their setups. I can post my charts all day here and each person would interpret them differently. I post a trading code and everyone has the exact same thing. I would think that's a potential problem...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Automating tape reading would be pretty straight forward. What are you looking for when you're tape reading? Large orders hitting the bid and a fast moving tape to give you a buy signal (in combination with other aspects of your system of course)? That could easily be incorporated into an automated system. I don't think there's any aspect of a good discretionary system that couldn't be automated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't think there's any aspect of a good discretionary system that couldn't be automated.

Hmmm...you sure about that ? You can program the emotional and psychological aspects of market behavior ? Also, your program can anticipate and interpret the "news" events ?

Omigosh, we are at least 10 years away from software being able to do this.

If we were "there" today, IBM's Big Blue program that crushed the best chess players would be applied to the markets. Guess what ? They tried it and it FAILED MISERABLY.

That was at least a 5 MAN-YEAR software effort...probably much more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't think there's any aspect of a good discretionary system that couldn't be automated.

 

Notouch - I think some aspects would be very difficult to code. For example, when trading candlesticks as I do, I can easily code what a hammer is by textbook definitions. But in real time, I am much more lenient on what I call a hammer. In intra-day trading, I think you have to be. So, while an automated system may be looking for picture perfect hammers, I may have taken other trades simply by 'eyeing' the charts up. And I wouldn't call one hammer better than the other, so to bypass the non-textbook hammer is a big mistake in my opinion.

 

I think it really boils down to what you are using in your trading. As you said, tape reading may be easily put into code. I have no idea if that's true, but it sounds like it could be. Your textbook candlesticks can easily be put into code as well, but that is one part of trading candlesticks in my opinion. A hammer that appears in chop is nothing to me.

 

I would love the ability to code my trading system in such a way that I know it will do what I can do on my own, if not better. And since I am unable to do this myself, there is strong hesitation to try to find a programmer that is willing and able to do it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Automating tape reading would be pretty straight forward. What are you looking for when you're tape reading? Large orders hitting the bid and a fast moving tape to give you a buy signal (in combination with other aspects of your system of course)? That could easily be incorporated into an automated system. I don't think there's any aspect of a good discretionary system that couldn't be automated.

 

I highly disagree and have to say it is impossible to code such a thing. Tape reading is not all about watching for big lots come across the tape. That is just the basics of it. I would love to elaborate on tape reading but I find it extremely difficult to explain in words. If everything can be automated... why is it that the majority of successful intraday traders are discretionary traders?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Market Climate ¡¡¡ Market Climate ¡¡¡ my dear fellow traders.... only a human trained neural net is in conditions to understand it.... sistems and computers will miserably fail.... lol and lol... there is no greater pleasure than to feel the market... once you feel it (click) cant live without it... its almost adictive... cheers Walter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In reply to syswizard: "emotional and psychological aspects of market behavior" are presumably reflected in the charts and tape or how else would a discretionary trader see them? So if they're reflected in the charts and the tape then they could be automated. And yes it is possible to analyse and interpret news events. In fact it's extremely simple to code an Excel macro that enters an order on the basis of an economic data release (released real time by Bloomberg and Reuters). Reuters, Bloomberg and Dow Jones also use XML tags that enable automated systems to react instantaneously to news events. Why do you think the market reaction to news events is instantaneous? Because automated systems are reacting within milliseconds - much faster than any discretionary trader could react.

 

Brownsfan: you could be as flexible in coding an automated system as you are in implementing a discretionary system. What are you looking for in interpreting your candles? For price to swiftly reverse on high volume? That can be coded into an automated system.

 

Soultrader: I'm sure it would be difficult to code a system that automates tape reading but definitely it's possible. I personally don't think the majority of successful intraday traders are discretionary traders. I think the majority of successful intraday retail traders are discretionary traders because it takes a high level of programming skills to write a successful automated system. I think the majority of intraday trades are executed by automated systems run by investment banks and other institutional traders. Definitely successful institutions are moving away from discretionary traders toward automated systems.

 

Just to clarify, I'm personally a discretionary trader but only because I don't have the programming abilities to put all my trading rules into an automated system.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[if] I post a trading code and everyone has the exact same thing. I would think that's a potential problem...
But that's the thing. The major charting software vendors do exactly that. They sell their product with default settings for all the indicators and they pretty much all set them at the same levels.

 

Guess what, most traders will take these packages on-board and will rarely think to examine the defaults or change them.

 

It's a potential problem all right, but only for those that don't think outside the shrink-wrap.

 

If you posted a piece of code I guarantee most would use it 'as is' without thinking to modify or test modifications of it. And you could then work out a pretty useful fade to what you'd supplied.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • A custom Better Daily Range indicator for MT5 is now available on the Metaquotes website and directly in the MT5 platform. https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/103800 The Better Daily Range indicator shows the previous trading day's price range on the current day's chart. Many traders mark out the previous day's high, low, and the current day's open before trading. This is not an average true range indicator (ATR). This is not an average daily range indicator (ADR). This is a daily range indicator (DR). This indicator shows horizontal maximum and minimum range lines. If your broker-dealer's MT5 platform shows Sunday bars, Sunday bars are not included as previous days. In other words, Monday uses Friday's price data (skips Sunday). This indicator also shows two 25% (of range) breakout lines: one that is 25% higher than the maximum range line, and one that is 25% lower than minimum range line. A middle range line is also shown. Immediately after the daily close of your broker-dealer, all five range lines update to the new daily values.   Many traders only trade during times of high volume/liquidity. The Better Daily Range indicator also shows five adjustable time separator lines: A local market open time line (a vertical line), A local market middle time A line (a vertical line), A local market middle time B (a vertical line), A local market middle time C (a vertical line), A local market close time (a vertical line), and A local market open price (a horizontal line). The location of the local market open price depends on your input local market open time. In other words, you input your desired market open time according to your local machine/device time and the indicator automatically shows all five session lines. When your incoming price bars reach your input local market open time line, the indicator automatically shows the price to appear at your input local market open time. If your broker-dealer's MT5 platform shows Sunday bars, the time separator lines do not show on a Sunday. Immediately after midnight local machine/device time, the five session time lines (vertical lines) are projected forward into the current day (into the future hours) and the local open price line is erased. The local open price line reappears when the price bars on the chart reach your input local open time (your local machine/device time).   The indicator has the following inputs (settings):   Chart symbol of source chart [defaults to: EURUSD] - Allows you to show data from another chart symbol other than the current chart symbol. Handy for showing standard timeframe data on an MT5 Custom Chart. Local trading session start hour [defaults to: 09] - Set your desired start hour for trading according to the time displayed on your local machine/device operating system (all times below are your local machine/device operating system times). The default setting, 09, means 9:00am. Local trading session start minute [defaults to: 30] - Set your desired start minute. The default setting, 30, means 30 minutes. Both the default hour and the default minute together mean 9:30am. Local trading session hour A [defaults to: 11] - Set your desired middle hour A for stopping trading when volume tends to decrease during the first half of lunch time. The default setting, 11, means 11:00am. Local trading session minute A [defaults to: 00] - Set your desired middle minute A. Both the default hour and the default minute together mean 11:00am. Local trading session hour B [defaults to: 12] - Set your desired middle hour B for the second half of lunch time. The default setting, 12, means 12:00pm (noon). Local trading session minute B [defaults to: 30] - Set your desired middle minute B. Both the default hour and the default minute together mean 12:30pm. Local trading session hour C [defaults to: 14] - Set your desired middle hour C for resuming trading when volume tends to increase. The default, 14, means 2:00pm. Local trading session minute C [defaults to: 00] - Set your desired middle minute C. Both the default hour and the default minute together mean 2:00pm. Local trading session end hour [defaults to: 16] - Set your desired end hour for stopping trading. The default setting, 16, means 4:00pm. Local trading session end minute [defaults to: 00] - Set your desired end minute for stopping trading. Both the default hour and the default minute together mean 4:00pm. High plus 25% line color [defaults to: Red]. High plus 25% line style [defaults to: Soid]. High plus 25% line width [defaults to 4]. High line color [defaults to: IndianRed]. High line style [defaults to: Solid]. High line width [defaults to: 4]. Middle line color [defaults to: Magenta]. Middle line style [defaults to: Dashed]. Middle line width [defaults to: 1]. Low line color [defaults to: MediumSeaGreen]. Low line style [defaults to: Solid]. Low lien width [defaults to: 4]. Low minus 25% line color [defaults to: Lime]. Low minus 25% line style [defaults to: Solid]. Low minus 25% line width [defaults to: 4]. Local market open line color [defaults to: DodgerBlue]. Local market open line style [defaults to: Dashed]. Local market open line width [defaults to: 1]. Local market middle lines color [defaults to: DarkOrchid]. Local market middles lines style [defaults to: Dashed]. Local market middles lines width [defaults to: 1]. Local market close line color [default: Red]. Local market close line style [Dashed]. Local market close line width [1]. Local market open price color [White]. Local market open price style [Dot dashed with double dots]. Local market open price width [1].
    • A custom Logarithmic Moving Average indicator for MT5 is now available for MT5 on the Metaquotes website and directly in the MT5 platform. https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/99439 The Logarithmic Moving Average indicator is a moving average that inverts the formula of an exponential moving average. Many traders are known to use logarithmic charts to analyze the lengths of price swings. The indicator in this post can be used to analyze the logarithmic value of price on a standard time scaled chart. The trader can set the following input parameters: MAPeriod [defaults to: 9] - Set to a higher number for more smoothing of price, or a lower number for faster reversal of the logarithmic moving average line study. MAShift [defaults to: 3] - Set to a higher number to reduce the amount of price crossovers, or a lower for more frequent price crossovers. Indicator line (indicator buffer) can be called with iCustom in Expert Advisors created by Expert Advisor builder software or custom coded Expert Advisors: No empty values; and No repainting.
    • A custom Semi-Log Scale Oscillator indicator is now available for MT5 on Metaquotes website and directly in the MT5 platform. https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/114705 This indicator is an anchored semi-logarithmic scale oscillator. A logarithmic scale is widely used by professional data scientists to more accurately map information collected throughout a timeframe, in the same way that MT5 maps out price data. In fact, the underlying logic of this indicator was freely obtained from an overseas biotech scientist. A log-log chart displays logarithmic values on both the x (horizontal) and y (vertical) axes, which generally produces a straight line that points up, down, or remains flat. A straight line is not very useful for trading markets because such a straight line is so smoothed that actual price values that appear over time are very far away from the line study. In contrast, a semi-log chart is only logged on one axis--generally, the y axis. Such a semi-log chart is well suited for trading markets because the time (x) axis is preserved in its original form while at the same time, providing a graduated y scale where the distance between price increments progressively increases as price rises higher (and decreases as price falls lower). This allows us to establish a zero level for a low price, clearly view trends on straighter angles, and clearly observe amplified price spikes at high prices. Accordingly, this indicator employs a semi-log scale on the y axis only. This indicator is anchored because it allows you to specify a start time for calculation of price bars. The settings are as follows: Year.Month.Day Hour:Minute - defaults to 1970.01.01 00:01 - if left on default setting, the indicator automatically detects the earliest price bar in chart history--even where the year 1970 is not in history. Notes appear in the indicator settings window. Size of first pip step to log - defaults to 135 - this default is suitable for higher timeframes such a MN1 (monthly), while 5 is suitable for lower timeframes such as M1 (minute). Ultimately, optimal settings will depend on the timeframe that you attach the indicator to, the level of price volatility within that timeframe, and start time that you choose. Remember... The semi-log formula calculates from low to high, so your start time must always be a major swing low. Again, notes appear in the indicator settings window. The standard (built-in) MT5 indicators that can be applied to the "Previous indicator's data" can be applied to this indicator. Indicator lines (indicator buffers) can be called with iCustom in Expert Advisors created by Expert Advisor builder software or custom coded Expert Advisors. The log scale Open, High, Low, and Close prices are buffers: No empty values; and No repainting.
    • A custom Gann Candles indicator is now available for MT5 on the Metaquotes website and directly in the MT5 platform. https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/126398 This Gann Candles indicator incorporates a series of W.D. Gann's strategies into a single trading indicator. Gann was a legendary trader who lived from 1878 to 1955. He started out as a cotton farmer and started trading at age 24 in 1902. His strategies included geometry, astronomy, astrology, times cycles, and ancient math. Although Gann wrote several books, none of them contain all of his strategies so it takes years of studying to learn them. He was also a devout scholar of the Bible and the ancient Greek and Egyptian cultures, and he was a 33rd degree Freemason of the Scottish Rite. In an effort to simplify what I believe are the best of Gann's strategies, I reduced them into one indicator that simply colors your preexisting price bars when those strategies are in-sync versus out-of-sync. This greatly reduces potential chart clutter. Also, I reduced the number of input settings down to only two: FastFilter, and SlowFilter Both FastFilter and SlowFilter must be set to 5 or more, as noted in the Inputs tab upon attaching the indicator to your chart. Gann Candles works on regular time-based charts (M5, M15, M20, etc.) and custom charts (Renko, range bars, etc.). The indicator does not repaint. When using the default settings, blue candles form bullish price patterns, gray candles form flat (sideways) price patterns, and white candles form bearish price patterns. The simplest way to trade Gann Candles is to buy at the close of a blue candle and exit at the close of a gray candle, and then sell at the close of a white candle and exit at the close of a gray candle.
    • A custom Anchored VWAP with Standard Deviation Bands indicator for MT5 is now available on the Metaquotes website and directly through the MT5 platform. https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/99389 The volume weighted average price indicator is a line study indicator that shows in the main chart window of MT5. The indicator monitors the typical price and then trading volume used to automatically push the indicator line toward heavily traded prices. These prices are where the most contracts (or lots) have been traded. Then those weighted prices are averaged over a look back period, and the indicator shows the line study at those pushed prices. The indicator in this post allows the trader to set the daily start time of that look back period. This indicator automatically shows 5 daily look back periods: the currently forming period, and the 4 previous days based on that same start time. For this reason, this indicator is intended for intraday trading only. The indicator automatically shows vertical daily start time separator lines for those days as well. Both typical prices and volumes are accumulated throughout the day, and processed throughout the day. Important update: v102 of this indicator allows you to anchor the start of the VWAP and bands to the most recent major high or low, even when that high or low appears in your chart several days ago. This is how institutional traders and liquidity providers often trade markets with the VWAP. This indicator also shows 6 standard deviation bands, similarly to the way that a Bollinger Bands indicator shows such bands. The trader is able to set 3 individual standard deviation multiplier values above the volume weighted average price line study, and 3 individual standard deviation multiplier values below the volume weighted average price line study. Higher multiplier values will generate rapidly expanding standard deviation bands because again, the indicator is cumulative. The following indicator parameters can be changed by the trader in the indicator Inputs tab: Volume Type [defaults to: Real volume] - Set to Tick volume for over-the-counter markets such as most forex markets. Real volume is an additional setting for centralized markets such as the United States Chicago Mercantile Exchange. VWAP Start Hour [defaults to: 07] - Set according to broker's or broker-dealer's MT5 server time in 24 hour format. For example, in the New York, United States time zone, 07 is approximately the London, United Kingdom business open hour. VWAP Start Minute [defaults to: 00] - Set according to broker's or broker-dealer's MT5 server time in 24 hour format. For example, 00 is on the hour with no delay of minutes within that hour. StdDev Multiplier 1 [defaults to: 1.618] - Set desired standard deviation distance between the volume weighted average price line study and its nearest upper and lower bands. For example, 1.618 is a basic Fibonacci ratio. Some traders prefer 1.000 or 1.250 here. StdDev Multiplier 2 [defaults to: 3.236] - Set desired standard deviation distance between the volume weighted average price line study and its middle upper and lower bands. For example, 3.236 is 1.618 (above) + 1.618. Some traders prefer 2.000 or 1.500 here. StdDev Multiplier 3 [defaults to: 4.854] - Set desired standard deviation distance between the volume weighted average price line study and its furthest upper and lower bands. For example, 4.854 is 1.618 (above) + 3.236 (above). Some traders prefer 3.000 or 2.000 here. VWAP Color [defaults to: Aqua] - Set desired VWAP line study color. This color automatically sets the color of the start time separators as well. SD1 Color [defaults to: White] - Set desired color of nearest upper and lower standard deviation lines. SD2 Color [defaults to: White] - Set desired color of middle upper and lower standard deviation lines. SD3 Color [defaults to: White] - Set desired color of furthest upper and lower standard deviation lines. Just to clarify, popular standard deviation bands settings are: 1.618, 3.236, and 4.854; or 1.000, 2.000, and 3.000; or 1.250, 1.500, and 2.000. Examples of usage *: In a ranging (sideways) market, enter a trade at the extremes of the standard deviation bands (SD3) and exit when price returns to the VWAP line study. Trade between SD1Pos and SD1 Neg, alternately buying and selling from one standard deviation line to the other. In a trending (rising or falling) market, enter a buy when a price bar opens above the VWAP line study, and exit at the nearest standard deviation band above (SD1Pos). Optionally, repeat the same trade but substitute SD1Pos for the VWAP, and SD2Pos for SD1. Reverse for sell; or Trade all lines (VWAP, SD1Pos, SD2Pos, and SD3Pos) in the same way. Again, reverse for sell. Indicator lines (indicator buffers) can be called with iCustom in Expert Advisors created by Expert Advisor builder software or custom coded Expert Advisors: No empty values; and No repainting.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.