Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Recommended Posts

Have a look at Spyder's Bar by Bar,

 

On bar 1, he speaks about increasing black volume and the price closes inside the previous bar, so a short is initiated. That black bar should be a red bar since the close is lower than the open, why is it black?

because it was higher than previous bar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Question for experts, how do you read these two laterals today and make money trading them. They both lasted 45 min each. It was like watching paint dry :) Thanks

Greenshot_2011-08-12_12-23-00.thumb.png.a65e8565a1ec754450a6f0f0c09c1cca.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Question for experts, how do you read these two laterals today and make money trading them. They both lasted 45 min each. It was like watching paint dry :) Thanks

 

I am not an expert but I am curious. Is this a trick?

 

The period is like a Friday lunch hour or pre-news time with VDU volume and narrow volatility. It started as a lateral, then failed break out, and then shifted slightly downward forming another lateral.

 

If you like thrill, I guess you could read DOM to scalp near the top and bottom of first lateral. The second lateral is converging and shows centering with tiny pennants. It is better to sit and wait for break out with increasing volume and possibly with quick reverse, no matter whether trend will be up or down.

 

:smoking:

 

[edit:] include off-market trading hours

Edited by SK0
adding some words.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Question for experts, how do you read these two laterals today and make money trading them. They both lasted 45 min each. It was like watching paint dry :) Thanks

you know its a lat because both colors are in down slope. you can a) stay out wait for pace quicken, higher volume bar or b) range trading, find your range sell top buy bottom again and again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Question for experts, how do you read these two laterals today and make money trading them. They both lasted 45 min each. It was like watching paint dry :) Thanks

 

The first is not a lateral. The 3rd bar is outside the boundaries of the first.

 

My advise regarding laterals:

 

- Look at 'the big picture' (the whole tape sequence)

- Annotate if it is a dominant or non-dominant lateral

- Notice/annotate FBO's/BO's

- Look at 100 sequences

 

Go back in the journals, laterals have been discussed many times.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Go back in the journals, laterals have been discussed many times.

 

I think we both need to go back and check the journals, below is Spyders wording

 

"The lateral formation continues until terminated with two closes outside the Lateral boundaries (created from the High / Low of Bar 1) - except where the 'two closes' form a 'flaw.' In such a case, we require a 'third' close outside the lateral boundary in order to have reached 'termination' of the previous lateral."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In order to give some help to beginners, I thought I share "the ultimate Volume Drill". I did this drill several months ago, when I was getting seriously into this method, and found it to be an absolute eye opener.

I had seen Spyder's admonition that "the answer might reside in the volume pane" so many times that I started wondering what I had been missing.

 

The idea of the drill is to draw every price bar (all 81 or them) by looking at the volume bars only, in realtime.

I practiced this drill for 2 weeks, all day long. At the beginning it was very frustrating, but towards the end I was amazed how much was revealed by the volume bars alone: I even started to correctly guess where a bar closed now and then, I could pick out doji bars etc.

I highly recommend this to anyone who has not done it... it instilled a habit to be aware of what volume is doing all of the time. Spyders's volume drills on ET- which had previously mystified me- became pretty clear.

 

One could do this drill by pasting a sheet of paper over the price portion on the monitor, but I think I found a better way.

The first thing you need is a screen-grab software. I am used to "Hypersnap": I find it easy and intuitive, but this is a personal preference, there are several inexpensive programs on the market.

My next post will contain the instructions in detail.

 

Attached please find some examples/results of this drill.The charts are pasted together EOD, the middle pane shows the actual price bars (invisible to me during the day), the upper pane the bars "guessed" during the day.

 

HTH, Vienna

04-13a.pdf

04-14a.pdf

04-19a.thumb.jpg.55e0088177a56eb2b83970d322f980b0.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Logging...in this case it was a remark by Mr. Black in one of the Journals, where someone had asked him a question and he said he found logging "indispensable". I thought "if it's good enough for Mr. B, it's good enough for me"...:)

 

I experimented with Logs, but was not satisfied until I had changed the format from vertical to horizontal, so the log actually goes left-to-right, like the chart...you can actually see the gaussians, which helps with clarity... perhaps useful for someone, modify as desired. If it already exists, I apologize...did not see any in this format.

You need 4 sheets per day, and it prints on legal. I use red and black pens for clarity.

 

Attached an example of a filled-in log and the excel file.

 

Cheerio,

 

Vienna

2011_04_11_4 logs.pdf

V LOG.xls

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One more resource (which I found invaluable) is having a mentor... I will not mention his name because I do not know if he likes to be approached etc., but I found to have someone who can help clarify things directly on skype, suggest drills etc. to be a huge help, and I am very grateful that someone gave me his time. Learning this by asking questions on a forum can be a bit like trying to learn Chinese by posting.

 

Of course, the actual work has to be done by the student, but it was my mentor e.g who suggested I do the volume drill...

 

Good trading,

 

Vienna

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
...

I practiced this drill for 2 weeks, all day long. At the beginning it was very frustrating, but towards the end I was amazed how much was revealed by the volume bars alone: I even started to correctly guess where a bar closed now and then, I could pick out doji bars etc.

I highly recommend this to anyone who has not done it... it instilled a habit to be aware of what volume is doing all of the time. Spyders's volume drills on ET- which had previously mystified me- became pretty clear.

...

 

HTH, Vienna

awesome!................

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quick questions;

 

What do the following stand for;

 

Vol (IBV,DBV)

Vol (I-V) and what are the levels eg 1.2 1.5

Mode (C,X)

 

Thanks

where do you see that? unless they come from a 'good' source you do best to just ignore it.

my best guess,ibv= increasing black volume, dbv=decreasing b v, i-v=increasing vol, c=continue,x=reverse maybe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quick questions;

 

What do the following stand for;

 

Vol (IBV,DBV)

Vol (I-V) and what are the levels eg 1.2 1.5

Mode (C,X)

 

Thanks

 

Vol (IBV,DBV) = Volume, IBV= Increasing Black Volume etc

Vol (I-V) and what are the levels eg 1.2 1.5= Pace levels (horizontal lines on Vol pane), 1.2= 1200 contracts

Mode (C,X) : C= continue, x= change

 

This is just the way I log things...as I said, please modify as desired.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well said, very frustrating

 

The best advice at the beginning I received was from Patrader...he suggested to read through the whole of the ET threads, first putting everybody but Spyder on ignore...that saves you months and helps eliminate confusion. Focus on the coarse tools only.

Yes, is a lot of work, I know...:-)

 

Also, start marking up charts, starting with the tapes.

 

hth,

 

Vienna

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Vol (I-V) and what are the levels eg 1.2 1.5= Pace levels (horizontal lines on Vol pane), 1.2= 1200 contracts

 

Hi Vienna,

 

Congratulations!

 

In the 2011_04_11_4 logs.pdf,

Bar 1 Vol-Level=2.6 (means 2600 contracts)

Bar 2 Vol-Level=2.82 (means 2820contracts)

Bar 3 Vol-Level=1.8 (means 1800contracts)

Bar 4 Vol-Level=1.8 (means 1800contracts)

 

In ninjatrader chart (please refer to the attachments for more information, in Asian timezone), the actual volume of Bar

1: 44936

2: 13522

3: 27911

4: 27144

 

What is Vol(I-V) in your log? TIA.

vienna2a.PNG.188d21598cb9bf92abf3a5b3d1ff5b79.PNG

vienna3a.thumb.PNG.5ed7c27ec9e5b8aaf1dd18f42a14cbbf.PNG

vienna4a.thumb.PNG.4187dc128cee075c63cdae671472e798.PNG

vienna5a.thumb.PNG.d55dbc5d69f41820bda64dd1c374a77a.PNG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The best advice at the beginning I received was from Patrader...he suggested to read through the whole of the ET threads, first putting everybody but Spyder on ignore...that saves you months and helps eliminate confusion. Focus on the coarse tools only.

Yes, is a lot of work, I know...:-)

 

Also, start marking up charts, starting with the tapes.

 

hth,

 

Vienna

glad to see you 'do the work' which I think pretty much the reply since the beginning of your quest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi Vienna,

 

Congratulations!

 

In the 2011_04_11_4 logs.pdf,

Bar 1 Vol-Level=2.6 (means 2600 contracts)

Bar 2 Vol-Level=2.82 (means 2820contracts)

Bar 3 Vol-Level=1.8 (means 1800contracts)

Bar 4 Vol-Level=1.8 (means 1800contracts)

 

In ninjatrader chart (please refer to the attachments for more information, in Asian timezone), the actual volume of Bar

1: 44936

2: 13522

3: 27911

4: 27144

 

What is Vol(I-V) in your log? TIA.

 

To be honest, I forgot how I used to log Volume. These days I note "20" when there is a 20k Vol bar...it's approximate.

Level I-V corresponds to the pace lines (DU- Extreme), but it does not really matter...just find a shorthand so that you have a RELATIVE measure of Volume. Check out what Pace+ Vol Peaks you have on the dominant legs versus the nondom legs...that's the point, does not matter how you classify it "A-D"..."I-V", whatever.

 

The important things of the log are 1. Find the items YOU deem important to track (they will change over time), and 2. find a vocabulary shortcut, a symbol etc. so that your notations only take seconds...otherwise you won't do it or you'll fall behind.

 

Spyder was not big on logging, but JH strongly recommends it...and so did Mr.B, as noted..

 

Anything that gets one to pay attention helps...:)

 

 

hth,

Vienna

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
glad to see you 'do the work' which I think pretty much the reply since the beginning of your quest.

 

Yes, seems to be the only way...was looking for shortcuts for at the beginning....unfortunately, didn't find any...:)

 

Good trading,

Vienna

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I realize this method works on any time frame as long as there is liquid volume. I would like to hear from people using it on a different time frame to 5min; the markets you are trading and the reason for choosing that time interval.

 

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I realize this method works on any time frame as long as there is liquid volume. I would like to hear from people using it on a different time frame to 5min; the markets you are trading and the reason for choosing that time interval.

 

Thanks

 

HSI -- 1 min

 

 

..........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I'm pretty sure that a Russian resident would say that recessions are real today. Their prime interest rate is 21%, their corporate military contractors are threatening to file bankruptcy, and sticks of butter are kept under lock and key in their grocery stores because shoplifters are stealing it in bulk so they can resell it on the black market. A downturn is cyclical until it turns into a collapse. I really don't think anyone will be buying-into this mess.😬
    • Well said. This principle is highly analogous to trading. Any human can easily click buy or sell when they "feel" that price is about to go up or down. The problem with feeling, commonly referred to as "instinctive" trading, is that it cannot be quantified. And because it cannot be quantified, it cannot be empirically tested. Instinctive trading has the lowest barrier to entry and therefore returns the lowest reward. As this is true for most things in life, this comes as no surprise. Unfortunately, the lowest barrier to entry is attractive to new traders for obvious reasons. This actually applied to me decades ago.🤭   It's only human nature to seek the highest amount of reward in exchange for the lowest amount of work. In fact, I often say that there is massive gray area between efficiency and laziness. Fortunately, losing for a living inspired me to investigate the work of Wall Street quants who refer to us as "fishfood" or "cannonfodder." Although I knew that we as retail traders cannot exploit execution rebates or queues like quants do, I learned that we can engage in automated scalp, swing, and trend trading. The thermonuclear caveat here, is that I had no idea how to write code (or program) trading algorithms. So I gravitated toward interface-based algorithm builders that required no coding knowledge (see human nature, aforementioned). In retrospect, I should never have traded code written by builder software because it's buggy and inefficient. However, my paid subscription to the builder software allowed me to view the underlying source code of the generated trading algo--which was written in MQL language. Due to a lack of customization in the builder software, I inevitably found myself editing the code. This led me to coding research which, in turn, led me to abandoning the builder software and coding custom algo's from scratch. Fast forward to the present, I can now code several trading strategies per day across 2 different platforms. Considering how inefficient manual backtesting is, coding is a huge advantage. When a new trading concept hits me, I can write the algo, backtest it, and optimize it within an hour or so--across multiple exchanges and symbols, and cycle through hundreds of different settings for each input. And then I get pages upon pages of performance metrics with the best settings pre-highlighted. Having said all of this, I am by no means an advanced programmer. IMHO, advanced programmers write API gateways, construct their own custom trading platforms, use high end computers with field programmable gateway array chips, and set up shop in close proximity to the exchanges. In any event, a considerable amount of work is required just to get toward the top of the "fishfood"/"cannonfodder" pool. Another advantage of coding is that it forces me to write trade entry and exit conditions (triggers) in black & white, thereby causing me to think microscopically about my precise trade trigger conditions. For example, I have to decide whether the algo should track the slope, angle, and level of each bar price and indicator to be used. Typing a hard number like 50 degrees of angle into code is a lot different than merely looking at a chart myself and saying, that's close enough.  Code doesn't acknowledge "maybe" nor "feelings." Either the math (code) works (is profitable) or doesn't work (is a loser). It doesn't get angry, sad, nor overly optimistic. And it can trade virtually 24 hours per day, 5 days per week. If you learn to code, you'll eventually reach a point where coding an algo that trades as you intended provides its own sense of accomplishment. Soon after, making money in the market merely becomes a side effect of your new job--coding. This is how I compete, at least for now, in this wide world of trading. I highly recommend it.  
    • VRA Vera Bradley stock watch, pull back to 5.08 support area at https://stockconsultant.com/?VRA
    • MU Micron stock watch, pull back to 102.83 gap support area with high trade quality at https://stockconsultant.com/?MU
    • ACLX Arcellx stock watch, trending at 84.6 support area with bullish indicators at https://stockconsultant.com/?ACLX
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.