Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Robert

Chart Patterns: Reliable?

Recommended Posts

Can one rely on strictly chart patterns to trade the markets? For example: triangle, wedges, flags, pennants, etc...

 

Do you think one can make money in the markets in the long run relying only on chart patterns? Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you ask some of the older and successful trading veterans, most used to hand-drawn chart patterns before modern technology. They never used anything else since the advent of the personal computer, except it has quicken their analysis. My mentor used it for 15 yrs, still making money today. Patterns are the meat of my trading. Not complaining so far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think undoubtedly yes. If you add a bit of 'context' so much the better. Of course realistic expectations are important! Just like any method patterns can fail but on balance they 'work'. It is because they tend to be a graphic representation of sentiment. (I guess some of the more exotic ones like Bats and Gartleys are less so). If you stick to flags, pennants, double tops, 2bs, 12'3s etc. You can develop profitable and simple strategies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe in the May issue of "Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities" magazine Bulkowski has an article discussing exactly this. He went back and ran some analysis on some of his previous patterns to see if their reliability had drop off in today's markets. I believe he was very surprised to find that their reliability was not what they once used to be and found far more failures than previously. You might want to have a read of the article to see exactly what he had to say about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chart patterns are reliable-- Mastering them is another subject....so too is Trading them profitably .

 

The problem that many have with patterns or their claim that chart patterns are not reliable is usually linked inexperience of understanding Price action or other variables like not enough time to master a pattern...to truely know it like the back of your hand and that takes time.

 

Part of the mastery is realizing that many variables influence any particular chart pattern that is trying to form. Because of this fact Programmatic back testing via a code usually will miss the value and the true reliability of chart patterns--In contrast a trader that has mastered his favorit chart patterns knows exactly when to trade them and when to let them go by. He has learned to be aware of the influencing variables and understands their impact on what he is trading , thus he can make appropriate adjustments on the fly.

Asking a Code to do the same thing is near impractical, unless you have a team of top notch programmers at your disposal and even then I dont think you would get the same results....some things just cant be communicated through code.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pappo is correct with his assessment of Pattern logic and coding/testing patterns.

In my experience, patterns do have excellent reliability with great repeatable logic.

Many successful traders have implemented patterns/code logic to take advantage of them.

Most pattern success or failure depends on knowing the pattern logic with market

context and knowing how/where they are forming. Without market context logic,

testing patterns is a futile exercise. Programmers tend to miss this logic when testing

patterns. Also, individual mastering of patterns requires thorough market knowledge

and experience and mastery may be limited to just few patterns. Coding patterns may be

more difficult for even most seasoned programmers too.

 

 

Excellent trading ideas are discarded due to poor coding and poor back-testing methods.

I have seen this many times in my career as many brilliant programmers with great ideas

but with little or no trading knowledge discard their concepts as not profitable due to

novice back-testing methods/results. Also, each trading platform have various trade

execution logic and hence many Automated Trading Systems back/forward testing results

suffer from wrong/poor execution methods.

 

 

Here is an example of a recent Bloomberg Article where TA was slandered.

 

"Stock Charts Fail Forecast Test in Complete S&P Miss (Update3)" by Michael Tsang and Eric Martin

 

Stock Charts Fail Forecast Test in Complete S&P Miss (Update3) - Bloomberg.com

 

Tsang and Martin (journalists) with little TA and no real trading/investing/programming

experience published an article and slandered the TA and indicators due to their wrong

back-testing results... Bloomberg published the article as it was written by their journalists.

Many TA experts (Murphy, McClellen et. al.) have written their concern to Bloomberg.

The editors at Bloomberg have softly admitted but sadly it was never removed.

 

Regards,

Suri

Edited by suriNotes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me the idea that a market is overbought or sold is absurd, yet people use stochastics like a "grail machine"....5,3,3 no 15,9,9....No 8,3,3.....No.....the Angle.....No the Cross of the stochs.....No.......the Macd with the stoch ...No...oh wait the 15 min must align with the 5 min.....No....wait the

Ema 34 must retrace before the CCI will give us a hook, oh yes , oh yes, oh yes, Meg Ryan in Harry met Sally now screams in the restaurant.......Eureka..........OH NO, There was news and the stochs of the 15m got tangled with the 5 and the leading index is at its monthly high plus the stoch is overbought, yes yes yes and now even Harry joins Meg ....oh no The fed killed us with the news, bloody hell maybe next time I will use a faster MA to compensate for the lack of feed accuracy due to my broker...oh wait that it, the feed is broken, I will buy a better feed : CQG(XXXX$), Bloomberg(xxxxxxxxx$) thats its , that was the problem the feed, oh wait its not the feed its the fact that I have to pea while trading, so I will read trading in the Zone again to distract my pain of trading through my Urinal glans directly unto the stoch 15,9,9 on the 3 Min which is the way to go, but wait my platform does not have Range Bars and everybody knows range bars are the way to go, unless the bottleneck is the CPU which is not strong enough to play DOOM and trade at the same time, so I will get a better CPU , oh wait, I have thunder storms so a great UPS is required....YES EUREKA ITS THE UPS GUYS, Much better than any technical analysis tool out there.

 

 

daily candle is it....lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For me the idea that a market is overbought or sold is absurd, yet people use stochastics like a "grail machine"....5,3,3 no 15,9,9....No 8,3,3.....No.....the Angle.....No the Cross of the stochs.....No.......the Macd with the stoch ...No...oh wait the 15 min must align with the 5 min.....No....wait the

Ema 34 must retrace before the CCI will give us a hook, oh yes , oh yes, oh yes, Meg Ryan in Harry met Sally now screams in the restaurant.......Eureka..........OH NO, There was news and the stochs of the 15m got tangled with the 5 and the leading index is at its monthly high plus the stoch is overbought, yes yes yes and now even Harry joins Meg ....oh no The fed killed us with the news, bloody hell maybe next time I will use a faster MA to compensate for the lack of feed accuracy due to my broker...oh wait that it, the feed is broken, I will buy a better feed : CQG(XXXX$), Bloomberg(xxxxxxxxx$) thats its , that was the problem the feed, oh wait its not the feed its the fact that I have to pea while trading, so I will read trading in the Zone again to distract my pain of trading through my Urinal glans directly unto the stoch 15,9,9 on the 3 Min which is the way to go, but wait my platform does not have Range Bars and everybody knows range bars are the way to go, unless the bottleneck is the CPU which is not strong enough to play DOOM and trade at the same time, so I will get a better CPU , oh wait, I have thunder storms so a great UPS is required....YES EUREKA ITS THE UPS GUYS, Much better than any technical analysis tool out there.

 

 

daily candle is it....lol.

 

 

Programmer,

 

You couldn't be more spot on. Thanks for the chuckle. I do a bit of training and have heard all of that buschwa again and again before the wannabees begin to learn. If it was that easy, you couldn't get a cab.

 

cheers

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Can one rely on strictly chart patterns to trade the markets? For example: triangle, wedges, flags, pennants, etc...

 

Do you think one can make money in the markets in the long run relying only on chart patterns? Thanks

 

Robert,

 

Practical answer: Yes.

You can trade ‘classic’ chart patterns successfully

> by placing a pattern in context / background. Others have described this well here and other threads.

> by being ok with sloppiness in their formation. Btw often on the right side of patterns, the obvious, ‘prettier’, more symmetrical patterns don’t seem to fair as well as the misshapen, ugly, unattractive ones. They get faded more?

> by implementing active position management, knowing where your pattern failure point is and ruthlessly stopping out there.

> by not expecting them to work. (rephrasing the preceding one in terms of attitude)

> by being patient, precise, and demanding with your entry placement.

> by developing skills at sizing proper scaling out– some before target, some at target, and some (as many as possible) left on for runners…

> by sizing correctly – this one might should be first!

 

 

Can one rely on strictly chart patterns to trade the markets? For example: triangle, wedges, flags, pennants, etc...

 

Do you think one can make money in the markets in the long run relying only on chart patterns? Thanks

 

BS (but better?) answer:

This is why the Zen master, when asked the nature of the Buddha, beats the student's head with a stick. Our words cannot convey participation or the realization to which participation can lead.

Here’s one for you – can you trade (except randomly) for an hour, a day, a week, or in any instance(s) - completely without the use of pattern?

The real question is - which patterns are YOURS? !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

PS In addition to Suri’s book, see Trading Commodity Futures with Classical Chart Patterns by Peter Brandt

Trading Commodity Futures with Classical Chart Patterns by Peter Brandt, ISBN: at the Global Investor Bookshop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a very wise anecdot from an Israeli Tech trader(Ob1..) freind of mine :

 

" A guy goes to a psychiatrist,

The doc says what's wrong?

The guy says I am seeing "body-parts" on charts.

The doc says what do you mean body parts?

The guy says I am seeing head and shoulders and some Bottoms on charts.

The doc says , that is bad, and gives him some Meds.

 

After two weeks the guy comes back to the doc.

 

The doc says, well do you still see body parts on charts?

The guys says, no, no more body parts.

The Doc says, do you see anything else?

The guy says, well I do see some butterflies and flags but not that often.

The doc says, its bad and gives him some more meds.

 

After two weeks the guy returns to the doc and says, Finally I don't see

anything on my charts, just charts.

The doc says' thats great, and gives him the Rorschach test, and tells him

well what do you see in the inkbolts?

The guy says I see complex scientifically derived algorithms..

The doc says thats great, maybe you should write a book on that.

 

A year later the guy publishes a book entitled" Body parts on charts", alas

nobody buys it, because they think the guy is a lunatic. So, the guy

changes the title to "Patterns on charts". Now, everybody buys the book,

and everybody is seeing butterflies, heads, shoulders, double bottoms,

tripe heads, even some claim that after reading the book they could swear

they saw the Monica/Clinton's Stain on the ES chart, which proved to be

an amazing reversal pattern.

 

Anyway, the book becomes a best seller along with titles like:

 

A GUIDE TO DATING ETIQUETTE , by Mike Tyson

 

FRENCH WAR HEROES. by Jacques Chirac

 

MY BEAUTY SECRETS, by Janet Reno

 

MY LITTLE BOOK OF PERSONAL HYGIENE,by Osama Bin Laden

 

AMELIA EARHART'S GUIDE TO THE PACIFIC

 

and THE AMISH PHONE DIRECTORY

 

 

Anyway the joke is on me because I bought the book...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Chart patterns are reliable-- Mastering them is another subject....so too is Trading them profitably .

 

The problem that many have with patterns or their claim that chart patterns are not reliable is usually linked inexperience of understanding Price action or other variables like not enough time to master a pattern...to truely know it like the back of your hand and that takes time.

 

Part of the mastery is realizing that many variables influence any particular chart pattern that is trying to form. Because of this fact Programmatic back testing via a code usually will miss the value and the true reliability of chart patterns--In contrast a trader that has mastered his favorit chart patterns knows exactly when to trade them and when to let them go by. He has learned to be aware of the influencing variables and understands their impact on what he is trading , thus he can make appropriate adjustments on the fly.

Asking a Code to do the same thing is near impractical, unless you have a team of top notch programmers at your disposal and even then I dont think you would get the same results....some things just cant be communicated through code.

Bulkowski has been successfully trading patterns for years. I came across his article after another trader I respect made a similar comment as something he had observed in trading. Its not that they don't work, but their reliability is tailing off. the other trader also mentioned that he had found increasing cases of patterns apparently failing but of you monitored them they would resume later than expected.

 

Chart patterns are essentially representations of people's beliefs about the market, these beliefs can be manipulated by the smart money operators.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • LZ LegalZoomcom stock, watch for a bull flag breakout at https://stockconsultant.com/?LZ
    • XMTR Xometry stock, watch for a local breakout above 37.5, target 44 area at https://stockconsultant.com/?XMTR
    • INTC Intel stock, nice bounce off the lower 19.12 triple+ support area at https://stockconsultant.com/?INTC
    • Date: 11th February 2025.   Market Update: Tariffs, Inflation, and Investor Sentiment Shape Global Markets.   Asian equities and US stock index futures experienced declines. At the same time, gold surged to a record high, reflecting investor caution following President Donald Trump’s announcement of new tariffs on US imports of steel and aluminium. Stock markets in Hong Kong and mainland China faced selling pressure, contributing to a regional downturn. Futures contracts for the S&P 500, Nasdaq 100, and Euro Stoxx 50 also traded lower. Meanwhile, Japanese markets remained closed due to a public holiday. Gold, often seen as a safe-haven asset duringeconomic uncertainty, extended its rally for a third consecutive session, briefly surpassing $2,942 before paring some gains. The US dollar index maintained its Monday gains, signalling sustained strength amid market volatility. The precious metal has surged about 11% this year, setting successive records as Trump’s disruptive moves on trade and geopolitics reinforce its role as a store of value in uncertain times. US Steel and Metals Sector Reacts to Tariffs Shares of US Steel Corporation surged as much as 6% following Trump’s announcement, as domestic metals producers saw a boost from the prospect of increased business and stronger pricing power. Canada, Brazil, and Mexico, the top steel suppliers to the US, are expected to be significantly impacted by these trade restrictions. Trump stated that the new tariffs, effective in March, aim to revitalize domestic production and job growth. However, he also suggested the possibility of further tariff increases, adding to market uncertainty.     Investor Concerns Over Tariffs and Trade War Escalation Investors are grappling with the implications of Trump’s tariffs, particularly in distinguishing between policy announcements and concrete actions. The uncertainty surrounding additional levies and potential retaliatory measures has reignited fears of an intensifying global trade war. Tariffs on Chinese goods are already in effect, and concerns persist about further economic fallout. According to Christian Mueller-Glissmann, head of asset allocation research at Goldman Sachs, the key challenge in portfolio strategy now lies in identifying assets that can effectively hedge against tariff risks. Speaking to Bloomberg Television, he noted, “The big challenge is that this is going to be much more difficult from here because the tariffs are very specific.” Key Economic Data and Federal Reserve Testimony in Focus Beyond trade tensions, investors are closely watching this week’s critical economic reports and statements from Federal Reserve officials. Fed Chair Jerome Powell is set to testify before Congress, while fresh inflation data will provide further insight into price trends. According to the New York Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer Expectations, inflation expectations for both the one-year and three-year outlooks remained steady at 3% in January. Short-term US inflation expectations have now risen above longer-term projections to their widest gap since 2023, signalling potential shifts in monetary policy. Inflation data, Powell’s congressional testimony, and tariffs are poised to drive the market today. A reprieve from negative surprises, such as the impact of DeepSeek, ongoing tariffs, and consumer sentiment concerns, could push S&P 500 to break out of its two-month consolidation.     Currency and Commodity Markets React The currency market also reflected shifting investor sentiment. The Japanese Yen remained largely unchanged. Meanwhile, the British Pound weakened after a report from the Financial Times cited Bank of England policymaker Catherine Mann’s concerns that weakening demand is beginning to outweigh inflationary risks. Gold’s continued ascent has been accompanied by significant inflows into bullion-backed exchange-traded funds. Global holdings have risen in six of the past seven weeks, reaching their highest levels since November. Banks have forecast that gold could test the $3,000 mark, with Citigroup predicting it could hit that level within three months and J.P. Morgan Private Bank projecting a year-end target of $3,150. Market Resilience Amid Trade Uncertainty Despite ongoing tariff tensions, equities have demonstrated resilience, leading some analysts to caution that further trade escalations could trigger renewed market pullbacks. Strategists at Deutsche Bank AG, including Binky Chadha, suggested that historical patterns indicate sharp but short-lived equity selloffs during geopolitical events, with markets typically rebounding before any formal de-escalation occurs. They projected that, in such scenarios, equity markets could decline by 6%-8% over a three-week period before recovering in a similar timeframe. China’s Growing Gold Reserves and Market Influence China’s central bank expanded its gold reserves for the third consecutive month in January, signalling an ongoing commitment to diversifying its holdings despite record-high prices. In addition, China introduced a pilot program allowing 10 major insurers to invest up to 1% of their assets in bullion for the first time. This initiative could translate into as much as 200 billion Yuan ($27.4 billion) in potential gold investments. Key Market Events to Watch This Week Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s semiannual testimony before the Senate Banking Committee today Speeches by Fed officials Beth Hammack, John Williams, and Michelle Bowman today US Consumer Price Index (CPI) report, Wednesday As global markets continue to navigate economic uncertainties, investors remain watchful of trade developments, monetary policy signals, and inflation trends that could shape the financial landscape in the coming weeks.   Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news.   Andria Pichidi HFMarkets   Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • KAR Openlane stock breakout at https://stockconsultant.com/?KAR
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.