Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

rsagi

NinjaTrader Stop Loss Bug - You May Looose $$$$

Recommended Posts

Hi All,

 

I'm using NinjaTrader 6.5.10008 (latest)

 

and I'm doing trade management using two target points and trailing the second target while using a stop loss that comes to break even+1 tick.

 

I ran into two issues today @ the FOMC day trading the ES:

 

1. I scalped the first few times in the heavy spikes of 2:22pm after the FOMC announcement and all was good (made money) - then a few times my target was hit (you hear the women voice ":target hit) so automatically I'm @ breakeven+1 tick - but then suddenly I see I lost $$$ !!! (this doesn't make sense - I went from +$720 to $120 and then -$120 -this problem occurred several times.

 

2. After the target was hit - there were some open orders - but I couldn't cancel them - so I figured they weren't active and disconnected from broker and connected again - and the problem was solved.

 

Needless to say I am angry with this problem - any1 else experience same thing?

:angry:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe you got slippage on the stop? Price can jump a bit round fomc. Don't stops need to be sent as stop limit to reside locally on Globex? Can't remember off the top of my head but I think that's correct.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Blowfish,

 

Well, I thought the do reside on the exchange - thats the whole idea of the stop isn't it... :)

 

If that is the case (slippage) that cannot be protected then I'll never trade FOMC days again.

 

Thanks fort he reply.

Steve

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

price needs to trade through your target not just to it i had the same issue when i first started using auto break even so have it move to BE at 7 ticks instead of 2 pts or what ever your number. also you will get slippage during FOMC days if your not prepared for that better to sit those days out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi Blowfish,

 

Well, I thought the do reside on the exchange - thats the whole idea of the stop isn't it... :)

 

If that is the case (slippage) that cannot be protected then I'll never trade FOMC days again.

 

Thanks fort he reply.

Steve

 

No, it varies exchange to exchange you need to check with your broker to be sure. From memory and unless its changed a stop will be held at your brokers or client platform, not on Globex. Eurex is the other way round. Over time exchanges are adding more order types but it used to be quite sobering to see how few are handled natively.

 

You would probably be surprised to find some exchanges don't even support market orders, they are converted to limit orders with wide limits :).

 

Believe what you please but I would check personally :)

 

Edit: OK I checked for you (senility makes you question yourself sometimes) Globex does not support stops or market orders nativey, so there you go. (guess I should have trusted my memory)

Edited by BlowFish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
No, it varies exchange to exchange you need to check with your broker to be sure. From memory and unless its changed a stop will be held at your brokers or client platform, not on Globex. Eurex is the other way round. Over time exchanges are adding more order types but it used to be quite sobering to see how few are handled natively.

 

You would probably be surprised to find some exchanges don't even support market orders, they are converted to limit orders with wide limits :).

 

Believe what you please but I would check personally :)

 

Edit: OK I checked for you (senility makes you question yourself sometimes) Globex does not support stops or market orders nativey, so there you go. (guess I should have trusted my memory)

 

Globex supports "Stops with protection" & "Market orders with protection"

 

Stop orders at CME Group are implemented using a “Stop with Protection” approach. Unlike a conventional Stop order, where customers

are at risk of having their orders filled at extreme prices, Stop with Protection orders are filled within a predefined range of prices (the protected range). A Stop with Protection order is triggered when the designated price is traded on the market. The order then enters the order book as a Limit order with the limit price equal to the trigger price, plus or minus the predefined protected range.

 

Market orders at CME Group are implemented using a “Market with Protection” approach. Unlike a conventional Market order, where customers are at risk of having their orders filled at extreme prices, Market with Protection orders are filled within a predefined range of prices (the protected range)

 

http://www.cmegroup.com/globex/files/GlobexRefGd.pdf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are using an ATM strategy in Ninja Trader it sets a Stop Limit order as folows: it places the stop side of the order at the price you asked for-in this case breakeven+1...it places the limit side of the order 20 ticks away in this case breakeven-19. This essentially makes this a market order that can be filled anywhere from your price to your price minus 20 ticks. In a fast moving market this can be disastrous, as you found out.

 

I have complained about this major flaw in NT for sometime and Ray has posted(in another forum) that this will be corrected in NT7. (it is important to remember that is the way NT handles ATM generated Stop/Limit orders on Globex, as some other exchanges do not allow Stop/Limit orders at all)

 

This only applies to a Stop/Limit generated by an ATM strategy, if you manually enter a Stop/Limit order you can select the offset you want in the preference window on the DOM.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are only really two options use a stop with no limit (or a wide limit on exchanges that don't natively support stop market) Then you risk slippage. Or use a stop with equal or tight limit and risk not being filled at all. Most people would prefer to be filled when there stops are hit unless perhaps stopping in to a position. There is no other way sadly. Knowing how your broker and the exchange handles various order types where they reside how they are elected etc. is pretty crucial imho.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ive been trading the ninja platform for a year using amp, I use stop market orders and have rarlely gotten any slippage occasionally i got a couple ticks. The biggest problems ive heard of from peolpe is usually that they get stoppped when placing orders if they're using a tight stop when theres a spike in activity and the screen freezes do to insufficiant computer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If you are using an ATM strategy in Ninja Trader it sets a Stop Limit order as folows: it places the stop side of the order at the price you asked for-in this case breakeven+1...it places the limit side of the order 20 ticks away in this case breakeven-19. This essentially makes this a market order that can be filled anywhere from your price to your price minus 20 ticks. In a fast moving market this can be disastrous, as you found out.

 

I have complained about this major flaw in NT for sometime and Ray has posted(in another forum) that this will be corrected in NT7. (it is important to remember that is the way NT handles ATM generated Stop/Limit orders on Globex, as some other exchanges do not allow Stop/Limit orders at all)

 

This only applies to a Stop/Limit generated by an ATM strategy, if you manually enter a Stop/Limit order you can select the offset you want in the preference window on the DOM.

 

Not only hasn't this bug been fixed, The other forum banned me and deleted the threads regarding this issue.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Not only hasn't this bug been fixed, The other forum banned me and deleted the threads regarding this issue.

 

Thanks BeyondMP for enlightening us on this issue. I have been testing several such ATM strategies on NT with stop limit orders using various futures (crude, yen, euro, etc) to be executed at fast moving news times. They have worked out pretty well on SIM. I gather I shouldn't get my hopes up when it comes to live trading though, correct?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks BeyondMP for enlightening us on this issue. I have been testing several such ATM strategies on NT with stop limit orders using various futures (crude, yen, euro, etc) to be executed at fast moving news times. They have worked out pretty well on SIM. I gather I shouldn't get my hopes up when it comes to live trading though, correct?

 

This major flaw imposes a mandatory 20 tick offset for all Stop Limit orders submitted thru an ATM. Consequently, if your profit target is less than 20 ticks away from entry, it is possible for a winner to turn into a loser in highly volatile and thinly traded market.

 

This flaw has the effect of turning those Stop Limit orders into market orders. In normal trading this can cause the trader to lose a tick or two on a very regular basis. This creates a "hidden" cost for using NT that can be many times the monthly fees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This major flaw imposes a mandatory 20 tick offset for all Stop Limit orders submitted thru an ATM. Consequently, if your profit target is less than 20 ticks away from entry, it is possible for a winner to turn into a loser in highly volatile and thinly traded market.

 

This flaw has the effect of turning those Stop Limit orders into market orders. In normal trading this can cause the trader to lose a tick or two on a very regular basis. This creates a "hidden" cost for using NT that can be many times the monthly fees.

 

Might there be a difference between data feeds, eg zen-fire vs some other feed when it comes to this issue? Also, what futures platform have you found that is superior in getting fills? (You mentioned something on another forum).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Might there be a difference between data feeds, eg zen-fire vs some other feed when it comes to this issue? Also, what futures platform have you found that is superior in getting fills? (You mentioned something on another forum).

 

This flaw is built in NT, it occurs regardless of data feed. Please understand, NT might be fine for some. If precise Stop Limit orders aren't important to you than NT might be ok. If precision is important than you will have to check with your broker, to find, which platform has the features you need.

 

As for me, I'll probably be switching to Sierra Charts when they can interface with my broker(which has an ETA of the end of the month).

 

I would not have even started this information campaign if Ray(the #1 guy at NT) hadn't lead me to believe this flaw would be fixed in NT7. I kept using NT for the past

1 1/2 years to show my support for his willingness to fix the flaw.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This major flaw imposes a mandatory 20 tick offset for all Stop Limit orders submitted thru an ATM. Consequently, if your profit target is less than 20 ticks away from entry, it is possible for a winner to turn into a loser in highly volatile and thinly traded market.

 

 

Thats boggling. Are you sure it is not up to 20 ticks (a 20 tick cap)? Most people would want to set the stop and limit at the same price I would guess (zero offset).

 

One has to ask why Ninja is using synthetic orders (simulating them on the client)? They should be submitted to the brokers system (or exchange if a native order) and modified if necessary. (certainly for stops and exits, some people might want the option to hold entry orders on the client so infrastructure problems mean unmanaged orders aren't left at thr broker/exchange). Reported all that in the beta of version 1 let alone 7!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thats boggling. Are you sure it is not up to 20 ticks (a 20 tick cap)? Most people would want to set the stop and limit at the same price I would guess (zero offset).

 

I'm absolutely sure. as a matter of fact NT tries to explain this limitation(flaw) as a benefit to the trader. I suppose it is to some...but, they fail to explain the added it costs it can impose to the trader's profitability.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm absolutely sure. as a matter of fact NT tries to explain this limitation(flaw) as a benefit to the trader. I suppose it is to some...but, they fail to explain the added it costs it can impose to the trader's profitability.

 

Wow so more like a Market if Touched order than a stop limit. Couple that with it being held on the client (presumably?) is a recipe for slippage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the major reasons traders use a trading platform like NT is it's ability to place bracket orders and to automate multi-step strategies. It is when using these strategies, the flaw comes into play.

 

Using the ES, which has a tick value of $12.50; a 20 tick stop equals $250. The problem comes into play on profit targets. These are sent out as Stop Limit orders. Because, the Stop side of the order is a mandatory 20 ticks away from the Limit side of the order....when the markets hits the Limit price, the 20 tick offset has the effect of turning the Limit order into a market order. This causes the Limit order to be filled at the best price available (within those 20 ticks).

 

This can cause a loss of a tick or two on a regular basis....Or, an extra $12.50-25.00 per contract traded. This can add substantially to the effective cost of using NT.

 

To be fair, you can change this offset after the order is submitted, but this is cumbersome and easy to forget to do in the "heat of trading." Remember, the reason you are paying NT is to automate these functions and make trading less stressful and reduce the steps of placing multiple orders.

 

You can take the position that slippage is inevitable. And, this is exactly the justification NT states...however, I know from my experience-and the way I trade- the market will come back and fill me at my Limit price, thus, achieving my full profit target.

 

There are traders that are happy to get filled at the "best price" but there others that trade with a greater precision and want the option to determine their own trading fate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

beyondMP,

Are you sure you are not thinking about a stop market with protection? What you are saying does not make sense. An order sent out as a stop limit is a stop limit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • PTCT PTC Therapeutics stock watch, trending with a pull back to 45.17 support area at https://stockconsultant.com/?PTCT
    • APPS Digital Turbine stock, nice rally off the 1.47 triple+ support area, from Stocks to Watch at https://stockconsultant.com/?APPS
    • Date: 20th December 2024.   BOE Sees More Support For Rate Cuts As USD Strengthens!   The US Dollar continues to rise in value after obtaining further support from positive economic and employment data. However, the hawkish Federal Reserve continues to support the currency. On the other hand, the Great British Pound comes under significant strain. Why is the GBPUSD declining? GBPUSD - Why is the GBPUSD Declining? The GBPUSD is witnessing bullish price movement for three primary reasons. The first is the Federal Reserve’s Monetary Policy, the second is the positive US news releases from yesterday and the third is the votes from the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee.     Even though the Bank of England chose to keep interest rates unchanged at 4.75%, the number of votes to cut indicates dovishness in the upcoming months. Previously, traders were expecting the BoE to remain cautious due to inflation rising to 2.6% and positive employment data. In addition to this, the Retail Sales data from earlier this morning only rose 0.2%, lower than expectations adding pressure to GBP. Investors also should note that the two currencies did not conflict and price action was driven by both an increasing USD and a declining GBP. The US Dollar rose in value against all currencies, except for the Swiss Franc, against which it saw a slight decline. The GBP fell against all currencies, except for the GBPJPY, which ended higher solely due to earlier gains. US Monetary Policy and Macroeconomics The bullish price movement seen within the US Dollar Index continues to partially be due to its hawkish monetary policy. Particularly, indications from Jerome Powell that the Fed will only cut on two occasions and the first cut will take place in May. However, in addition to this the economic data from yesterday continues to illustrate a resilient and growing economy. This also supports the Fed’s approach to monetary policy and its efforts to push inflation back to the 2% target. The US GDP rose 3.1% over the past quarter beating expectations of 2.8%. The GDP rate of 3.1% is also higher than the first two quarters of 2024 (1.4% & 3.0%). In addition to this, the US Weekly Unemployment Claims fell from 242,000 to 220,000 and existing home sales rose to 4.15 million. Home sales in the latest month rose to an 8-month high. For this reason, the US Dollar rose in value against most currencies throughout the day. Analysts believe the US Dollar will continue to perform well due to less frequent rate cuts and tariffs. The US Dollar Index trades 1.65% higher this week. Bank of England Sees Increased Support for Rate Cuts! The Bank of England kept interest rates unchanged as per market’s previous expectations. The decision is determined by a committee of nine members and at least five of them must vote for a cut for the central bank to proceed. Analysts anticipated only two members voting for a cut, but three did. This signals a dovish tone and increases the likelihood of earlier rate cuts in 2025. The three members that voted for a rate cut were Dave Ramsden, Swati Dhingra, and Alan Taylor. Advocates for lower rates believe the current policy is too restrictive and risks pushing inflation well below the 2.0% target in the medium term. Meanwhile, supporters of keeping the current monetary policy argue that it's unclear if rising business costs will increase consumer prices, reduce jobs, or slow wage growth. However, if markets continue to expect a more dovish Bank of England in 2025, the GBP could come under further pressure. In 2024, the GBP was the best performing currency after the US Dollar and outperformed the Euro, Yen and Swiss Franc. This was due to the Bank of England’s reluctance to adjust rates at a similar pace to other central banks. GBPUSD - Technical Analysis In terms of the price of the exchange, most analysts believe the GBPUSD will continue to decline so long as the Federal Reserve retains their hawkish tone. The exchange rate continues to form lower swing lows and lower highs. The price trades below most moving averages on the 2-hour timeframe and below the neutral level on oscillators. On the 5-minute timeframe, the price moves back towards the 200-bar SMA, but sell signals may materialise if the price falls back below 1.24894.     Key Takeaways: The US Dollar increases in value for a third consecutive day and increases its monthly rise to 2.32%. The US Dollar Index was the best performing currency of Thursday’s session, along with the Swiss Franc. US Gross Domestic Product rises to 3.1% beating economist’s expectations of 2.8%. US Weekly Unemployment Claims read 220,000, 22,000 less than the previous week and lower than expectations. The NASDAQ declines further and trades 5.00% lower than the previous lows. The GBPUSD ends the day 0.56% lower and falls more than 1% after the Bank of England’s rate decision. Three Members of the BoE vote to cut interest rates. The GBP was the worst performing currency of the day along with the Japanese Yen. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news. Michalis Efthymiou HFMarkets Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • Date: 19th December 2024.   Federal Reserve Sparks NASDAQ’s Sharpest Selloff of 2024!   The NASDAQ fell more than 3.60% after the Federal Reserve cut interest rates, but gave hawkish comments. The stock market saw its largest decline witnessed in 2024 so far, as investors opted to cash in profits and not risk in the short-medium term. What did Chairman Powell reveal, and how does it impact the NASDAQ? The NASDAQ Falls To December Lows After Fed Guidance! The NASDAQ and US stock market in general saw a considerable decline after the press conference of the Federal Reserve. The USA100 ended the day 3.60% lower and saw only 1 of its 100 stocks avoid a decline. Of the most influential stocks the worst performers were Tesla (-8.28%), Broadcom (-6.91%) and Amazon (-4.60%).     When monitoring the broader stock market, similar conditions are seen confirming the investor sentiment is significantly lower and not solely related to the tech industry. The worst performing sectors are the housing and banking sectors. However, investors should also note that the decline was partially due to a build-up of profits over the past months. As a result, investors could easily sell and reduce exposure to cash in profits and lower their risk appetite. Analysts note that despite the Federal Reserve's hawkish stance, the Chairman provided a positive outlook. He highlighted optimism for the economy and the employment sector. Therefore, many analysts continue to believe that investors will buy the dip, even if it’s not imminent. A Hawkish Federal Reserve And Powell’s Guidance Even though traditional economics suggests a rate cut benefits the stock market, the market had already priced in the cut. As a result, the rate cut could no longer influence prices. Investors are now focusing on how the Federal Reserve plans to cut in 2025. This is what triggered the selloff and the decline. Investors were looking for indications of 3-4 rate cuts by the Federal Reserve in 2025 and for the first cut to be in March. However, analysts advise that the forward guidance by the Chairman, Jerome Powell, clearly indicates 2 rate adjustments. In addition to this, analysts believe the Fed will now cut next in May 2025. The average expectation now is that the Federal Reserve will cut 0.25% on two occasions in 2025. The Fed also advised that it is too early to know the effect of tariffs and “when the path is uncertain, you go slower”. This added to the hawkish tone of the central bank. However, surveys indicate that 15% of analysts believe the Federal Reserve will be forced into cutting rates at a faster pace. As a result, the US Dollar Index rose 1.25% and Bond Yields to a 7-month high. For investors, this makes other investment categories more attractive and stocks more expensive for foreign investors. However, the average decline the NASDAQ has seen before investors buy the dip is 13% ($19,320). This will also be a key level for investors if the NASDAQ continues to decline. NASDAQ - Technical Analysis Due to the bearish volatility, the price of the NASDAQ is trading below all major Moving Averages and Oscillators on the 2-Hour chart. After retracement the oscillators are no longer indicating an oversold price and continue to point to a bearish bias. Sell indications are likely to strengthen if the price declines below $21,222.60 in the short-term.       Key Takeaways: A hawkish Federal Reserve cut interest rates by 0.25% and indicates only 2 rate cuts in 2025! The stock market witnesses its worst day of 2024 due to the Fed’s hawkish forward guidance. Economists do not expect a rate cut before May 2025. Housing and bank stocks fell more than 4%. Investors are cashing in their gains and not looking to risk while the Fed is unlikely to cut again until May 2025. The US Dollar Index rises close to its highest level since November 2022. US Bond Yields also rise to their highest since May 2024. The NASDAQ’s average decline in 2024 before investors opt to purchase the dip is 13%. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news. Michalis Efthymiou HFMarkets Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • SNAP stock at 11.38 support area at https://stockconsultant.com/?SNAP
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.