Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Soultrader

Discretionary and Mechanical Trading: Finding Balance

Recommended Posts

I wanted to start a new thread as I have recently gone through a transformation in my trading. For the past 3 years, I have been a purely discretionary trader relying on volume, tape, and market profile.

 

With a new market (shift from US futures to Nikkei futures) I had to dump all of my methodology and find new techniques to trade. Market profile is not a tool available through my current platform and prop firm, VSA techniques do not work as well with the Nikkei, and market profile is not as efficient.

 

First, the Nikkei gaps every single day due to the US markets and the time difference. On many occasions, the previous day profile becomes absolutely useless due to these gaps. There are no premarket sessions and as a result you can not see any premarket support or resistance. Gaps tend to not fill as well. So basically, all I have learned trading the US futures did not work with the Nikkei futures.

 

I struggled to find a methodology to trade this market. I first starting drawing MP charts manually, then started filtering out the tape, then started to focus on candlevolume charts. I realized that this market was dominated by automated systems and big lot scalpers.

 

Here is what I have done that has transformed my way of trading. I never thought I would become this type of trader. My trading is now 70% automated. I have about 6 strategies that look to exploit rejection patterns and follow trends. These are all automated through excel and give me buy/sell signals for various instruments and timeframes. I also apply parameters based on open/close/low/high/volume.

 

The only discretionary part is to decide whether to take the signal and my exit on my last quarter position. (3/4 position is fixed targets per strategy)

 

This has really changed the way I approach trading as it has taken away alot of the emotional elements of trading.

 

First, 2 years of data mining the Nikkei futures has showed me that the market trends intraday only about 25% of the time. Therefore, the edge lies in reversals and fading IB breakouts.

 

How many traders here use both a mechanical and discretionary approach in trading? The number one element that changed my trading is how I used to be glued to tape. Now, I hardly look at any charts but watch spreadsheets all day long.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How has the transition from a system you've developed for over 4 years to this new spread sheet type trading effected you James? It must be a real shock to your system to have to basically learn to trade all over again!

 

Has your new system produced decent results for you?

 

Sounds all very interesting but also I can't imagine looking at spread sheets all day, would do my head in!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My first month was extremely suprising and frustrating as most of the techniques that I am familiar with did not work. I spent hours and hours backtesting momentum strategies, chart patterns, candle based conditionals, and this is what I was able to come up with in approximately 1 month. I am still brainstorming strategies and devising them as the day progresses. But unlearn and learning is a very hard process.

 

I have attached a snapshot of my semi-automated trading system. Other than this, I scalp off the tape on a few stocks and the index futures through tape.

 

Spreadsheet.JPG

 

Note that I do not take any signals after 2:30pm. Anything after 3:10pm represents evening session hours in which there is hardly any liquidity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see that you're operating on a slightly higher time frame than when you first started making videos on this site. I can't tell for sure but are you becoming more of a counter trend trader now? The 5 and 30 min time frames would make it easier to set up your trades when trading off the spread sheet like that. Hehe I feel sorry for your eyes though!

 

Btw love your little TRIN calculator :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I have mulled over your quite though provoking post. Despite this the thoughts have not really crystallised so I'll just spurt a couple of ideas out half baked!

 

Firstly congratulations, I think its probably a mark of great maturity as a trader that you can change markets and methods and do what it takes to get the job done. Tools are just that - its the cook that makes the meal not the robocheff 2000 delux food processor.

 

Markets sometimes just act up or maybe the trader is just off his game....I think even if he is off his game markets still 'act up' sometimes. For example recently the DAX has been 'weird' with regards volume and spread.

 

Sometimes tools need a tune up for a market. I was thinking MP - for example if there are gaps use something like Jerry's developing MP for the current day, or the MP for the last time that price traded at this level. If Use VSA on hourly bars rather than 5 miutes etc.

 

Finally where to set the discretionary <-----> full mechanical slider. That's a real toughy. Some things are inherently 'visual', channel lines, VSA, tape reading. Personally I feel a draw to these types of methods. The dowside is they are quite hard to make more 'mechanical' so discipline becomes a big issue (for me at least).

 

Anyway got to run...travelling again... for me it was a thought provoking post on a couple of levels.

 

Cheers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

James,

 

One of my favorites: The Ultimate Trading Guide by John R. Hill, George Pruitt, Lundy Hill, is a must read for mechanical trading ideas. John R. Hill is the President and founder of futures Truth, a leading newsletter that analyzes and rates trading systems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally once I had a system that I was really confident in, which was in essence really quite simple, I wouldn't hesitate to automate a large part of it to deal with the most basic set ups simply so I could have more time to watch other setups. While I'm not a fan of 100% mechanical systems I do believe they can be beneficial when you use them to free up time that could be spent on other trades.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How many traders here use both a mechanical and discretionary approach in trading? The number one element that changed my trading is how I used to be glued to tape. Now, I hardly look at any charts but watch spreadsheets all day long.

 

Dohhh...I have forgot to even check the premium section of this board in months.

I've just started to move down this path as I'm finally getting the hang of C# and Ninja.

James, what are you using to data mine, just excel? Thats absolutely my focus right now. Have you ever read the "System Development with acrary" thread on elite trader? I think thats far better than any systems book available. One thing he mentions in there that I would like to eventually evolve towards is he has his automated systems and then when he is around he tries to front run them discretionary wise. I think thats a pretty interesting way to trade.

Here is the first potentially useful thing I've done with data mining(if you can call it that) Basically tried to take the daily average range of 5 minute bars on SPY with Ninja and then plot them in Excel. Seems to be a pretty interesting indicator of volatility. The data is not totally accurate as I think I'm missing some of monday morning sessions from my newbness with ninja. Its interesting how that first big spike up in feb 07 had more volatility and a bigger range but was orderly. Current volatility/range is just schitzo.

SPYrange5min.jpg.3a85c58c7e35d37185ec4702982da126.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Here is what I have done that has transformed my way of trading. I never thought I would become this type of trader. My trading is now 70% automated. I have about 6 strategies that look to exploit rejection patterns and follow trends. These are all automated through excel and give me buy/sell signals for various instruments and timeframes. I also apply parameters based on open/close/low/high/volume.
This is precisely what has happened to me over the last few months. I have gone from a discretionary trader with some mechanical rules to mostly mechanical. The biggest change I have seen is how I manage my money. With my discretionary style I would put large positions on and start the scaling out process quickly with a distance target area for the last trailer. With my mechanical trading I use less leverage and exit at one to three target areas depending on the setup. The surprising result is that my average profit has almost stayed the same. However, these two systems are not equal by any means! The mechanical style has been more consistent (less draw down) and has allowed me to explore trading multiple instruments. These advantages are extremely important when scaling up. My current goal is to make the research and recognition part as automated as possible so I can keep track of dozens of instruments and only trade the highest probability setups. Of course like everything else in trading...easier said than done. Programming can be a PAIN IN THE A$$.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I wanted to start a new thread as I have recently gone through a transformation in my trading. For the past 3 years, I have been a purely discretionary trader relying on volume, tape, and market profile.

 

With a new market (shift from US futures to Nikkei futures) I had to dump all of my methodology and find new techniques to trade. Market profile is not a tool available through my current platform and prop firm, VSA techniques do not work as well with the Nikkei, and market profile is not as efficient.

 

First, the Nikkei gaps every single day due to the US markets and the time difference. On many occasions, the previous day profile becomes absolutely useless due to these gaps. There are no premarket sessions and as a result you can not see any premarket support or resistance. Gaps tend to not fill as well. So basically, all I have learned trading the US futures did not work with the Nikkei futures.

 

Surprised to read this and curious about it as well... aren't we taught that most principles and 'guidelines' work amongst all markets, regardless of what timeframe we choose or what kind of market it is (provided there's sufficient liquidity)?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Soul is correct.

 

The US tricks don't work well on SPI or STW either although at least Wyckoff style volume interpretation works intraday with them. With HSI even the volume is unreasonably deceptive.

 

Personally I establish intraday trends and then microswing trade the trends until they reverse (if they do) and then swing the other way.

 

Here's a 15 min spi chart. SPI trades ~24hrs so you can see the effect of the Euro/US timezones which I show blue on my charts.

.

spi15.png.91717d3df7e330e5d27b9684edcb8b44.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • HLF Herbalife stock, watch for a bull flag breakout above 9.02 at https://stockconsultant.com/?HLF
    • Date: 1st April 2025.   Will Gold’s Rally Hold Strong as New Trade Tariffs Take Effect Tomorrow?   Gold continues to increase in value for a sixth consecutive day and is trading more than 17% higher in 2025. Amid fear of higher inflation, a recession and the tariffs war escalating investors continue to invest into Gold pushing demand higher. The trade policy from April 2nd onwards continues to be a key factor for the whole market. Can Gold maintain its upward trend? Trade Policy From Tomorrow Onwards Starting as soon as tomorrow, a 25% tariff will be imposed on all passenger cars imported into the United States. While this White House policy is anticipated to negatively affect European industrial performance, it will also lead to higher transportation and maintenance costs for everyday American taxpayers. The negative impact expected on both the EU and US is one of the reasons investors continue to buy Gold. Additionally, last month, President Donald Trump announced reciprocal sanctions against any trade partners that impose import restrictions on US goods. Furthermore, tariffs on products from Canada and the EU could increase even more if they attempt to coordinate a response. Overall, investors continue to worry that new trade barriers will prompt retaliatory measures, particularly from China, the Eurozone, and Japan. Any retaliation is likely to escalate the trade conflict and prompt another reaction from the US. Experts at Goldman Sachs and other investment banks warn that this will lead to rising inflation and unemployment. They also caution that it could effectively halt economic growth in the US.   XAUUSD 1-Hour Chart   The Weakness In The US Dollar Another factor which is allowing the price of XAUUSD to increase in value is the US Dollar which has been unable to maintain any bullish momentum. Despite last week’s Core PCE Price Index rising to its highest level since February 2024, the US Dollar has been unable to see any significant rise in value. Due to the US Dollar and Gold's inverse correlation, the price of Gold is benefiting from the Dollar weakness. Investors worry that new trade barriers will prompt retaliatory measures from China, the Eurozone, and Japan, potentially escalating the conflict. Experts at The Goldman Sachs Group Inc. believe that such actions by the US administration will drive rising inflation and unemployment while effectively halting economic growth in the country. Can Gold Maintain Momentum? When it comes to technical analysis, the price of Gold is not trading at a price where oscillators are indicating the instrument is overbought. The Relative Strength Index currently trades at 68.88, outside of the overbought area, since Gold’s price fell 0.65% during this morning’s session. However, even with this decline, the price still remains 0.40% higher than the day’s open price. In terms of fundamental analysis, there continues to be plenty of factors indicating the price could continue to rise. However, the price movement of the week will also partially depend on the employment data from the US. The US is due to release the JOLTS Job Vacancies for February this afternoon, the ADP Non-Farm Employment Change tomorrow, and the NFP Change and Unemployment Rate on Friday. If all data reads higher than expectations, investors may look to sell to lock in profits at the high price. Key Takeaway Points: Gold’s Rally Continues – Up 17% in 2025 as investors seek safety from inflation, recession fears, and trade tensions. Trade War Impact – New US tariffs and potential retaliation from China, the EU, and Japan drive uncertainty, boosting Gold demand. Weak US Dollar – The Dollar’s struggle supports Gold’s rise due to their inverse correlation. Gold’s Outlook – Uptrend may continue, but US jobs data could trigger profit-taking. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news.   Michalis Efthymiou HFMarkets   Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • Date: 31st March 2025.   Trump Confirms Tariffs on All Countries, Sending Stocks Lower.   The NASDAQ continues to trade lower due to the US confirming the latest tariffs will be on all countries. In addition to this, bearish volatility also is largely due to the higher inflation data from Friday. The NASDAQ declines to its lowest price since September 11th 2024. Core PCE Price Index - Inflation Increases Again! The PCE Price Index read 2.5% aligning with expert forecasts not triggering any alarm bells. However, the Core PCE Price Index rose from 0.3% to 0.4% MoM and from 2.7% to 2.8% YoY, signalling growing inflationary pressure. This increases the likelihood that the Federal Reserve will maintain elevated interest rates for an extended period. The NASDAQ fell 2.60% due to the higher inflation reading which is known to pressure the stock market due to pressure on consumer demand and a more hawkish Federal Reserve. Boston Fed President Susan Collins recently commented that tariffs could drive up inflation, though the long-term impact remains uncertain. She told journalists that a short-term spike is the most probable outcome but believes the current pause in monetary policy adjustments is appropriate given the prevailing uncertainties. Although, certain investment banks such as JP Morgan actually believe the Federal Reserve will be forced into cutting rates. This is due to expectations that the economy will struggle under the new trade policy. For example, JP Morgan expects the Federal Reserve to delay rate cuts but will quickly cut towards the end of 2025. Market Risk Appetite Takes a Hit! A big factor for the day is the drop in the risk appetite of investors. This can be seen from the VIX which is up almost 6%, Gold which is trading 1.30% higher and the Japanese Yen which is the day’s best performing currency. Most safe haven assets, bar the US Dollar, increase in value. It is also worth noting that all indices are decreasing in value during this morning's Asian session with the Nikkei225 and NASDAQ witnessing the strongest decline. Previously the stock market rose in value as investors heard rumours that tariffs would only be on certain countries. This bullish swing occurred between March 14th and 25th. Over the weekend, President Donald Trump indicated that the upcoming tariffs would apply to all countries, not just those with the largest trade imbalances with the US. NASDAQ - Technical Analysis In terms of technical analysis, the NASDAQ continues to obtain indications that sellers control the price action. The price opens on a bearish price gap measuring 0.30% and trades below all Moving Averages on all timeframes. The NASDAQ also trades below the VWAP and almost 100% of the most influential components (stocks) are declining in value.     The next significant support level is at $18,313, and the resistance level stands at $20,367.95. Key Takeaway Points: NASDAQ falls to its lowest since September 2024 as the US confirms tariffs on all countries, adding to inflation concerns. Core PCE inflation rises to 0.4% MoM and 2.8% YoY, increasing the likelihood of prolonged high interest rates. Investor risk appetite drops as VIX jumps 6%, gold gains 1.3%, and safe-haven assets outperform. NASDAQ shows strong bearish momentum, trading below key technical levels with support at $18,313 and resistance at $20,367.95. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.   Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.   Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar.   Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding of how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!   Click HERE to READ more Market news.   Michalis Efthymiou HFMarkets   Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in Leveraged Products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • PM Philip Morris stock, top of range breakout at https://stockconsultant.com/?PM
    • EXC Exelon stock, nice range breakout at https://stockconsultant.com/?EXC
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.