JohnE

Does the $ 67 pdf give you a good summary of the method or do we need to buy the DVD? I guess the real question is how much add on stuff do we need to buy with emini junkie in order to undersytand the method? Thank you!

In one post Jpearl compares the Volume histogram high volume price( PVP) to the POC in market porofile......I want to get started on the right track while digesting these threads so Isn't the POC based on TIME where as the PVP is based on volume....a very big differnce sometimes..... Is Jerry assuming most MP players now use Volume for their MP charts in stead of time...? Thanks for any input JE

Is this the same person who use to be in JPJtrading room..? she liked the dax and 10 and 20 points off weekly numbers etc....

How come you keep jumping from room to room Koifan...? I'm curious...what happened to Reza and Eric......where they not profitable or was the room not a match for you ? I too would like to further my MP knowledge but not sure which room would be right for me..Thanks for your feedback.... Marker - could you tell us more about your one month trial....was it educational or just posting of trades JE

Omni, I know somewhere it was mentioned that you are currently involved in Daltons training so I'll aim this question at you but obviously it is open for everyone. In Mind over Markets Dalton writes at great length of the open price in relation to the previous days Value area and how to measure/estimate ranges for the day. He also writes about double TPO acceptance above/below value. It seems that having the two key ways to get at a value area ( TPO's and Volume) adds even more subjectivity to Market profile and the specific topics I just mentioned. I was wondering if those concepts are still valid or does Dalton not address the days open anymore? We may have an open outside of Value using one method but inside value using the other for example. Perhaps Dalton can elaborate for us on this and you can report back. Thank you. JE

Any of you math pro's know what the multiplier would be to calculate the Volatility bands after the first hour has transpired ? How about after two hours of trading? Then three etc.....It would save me from dusting off my old math books from the 60's.....Do we use a 24 hour day or the actual trading day hours ? Thanks JE

What a fantastic effort from Jperl and all those who interacted on that VWAP/statistical thread...thanks so much. I was wondering if someone could post a 2 minute ES chart from Fridays day session only showing the VWAP and the standard deviation bands. I'm not sure if mine are running right as the 2nd SD band doesn't get hit that often and the third hangs out in the middle of nowhere, but perhaps it is the nature of the bands. I'd also like to know if most use an "all sessions" VWAP chart because it may show better zones or if the day session is good enough......I'm hoping to not have to run two different VWAP charts at the same time ( day and all sessions). Thanks for the help. JE

we look forward to it...

I'm certainly no math wizard but doesn't those 4PM (est) cash close volume spikes mess up the volume profiles each day? thanks for the responses.... JE

This is my first or second post so a hearty "Thank you" for a fantastic forum. So much great information here. My question is regarding the "correct" method for calculating the Value area numbers specifically for the Emini S&P... Some days they are quite different. I'm trying to eliminate lines on my screen and not add more price levels. Does anyone know of any studies that have compared the two methods to determine which numbers are "best " to use? Volume or TPO's.....which do most feel are watched by the "pro's"......thanks for any guidance/direction you may offer.... JE

Hi Everyone, I'm a new poster here. Has Alex changed the way he uses and establishes targets? I am familiar with his 2 day IB for the weekly IB and the first 5 days of the month for the monthly IB but in this video he seems to be using other forms of targets with the profile. I couldn't follow it completely due to the chart size etc........does anyone have a summary of these techniques? When does his book come out? Great site you have here. I've been a lurker for years...thanks for all of it JohnE