Omrudra

Hi, I might have been guilty of that exactly. Point noted. Rereading all the basics as I write. Thanks Omrudra

Hi, Thank you for the reply. I have observed in some of the analysis of charts by VSA on this forum, videos and my experience,that there can be more than one no demand or no supply before the market actually moves,especially after a major accumulation or distribution. My question would be, how would one determine which is the indicator that 'triggers' the move? ( of course taking in to consideration SOS and SOW in the back ground). Is not timing ,knowing when as important as knowing how, the market moves. Kind Regards, Omrudra

Hi, Thank you for your reply and the charts. Even though I concur with your opinion about looking into the back ground,is not days/weeks too large a time frame for a liquid instrument like bund futures where large movements take place hourly if not minutes. Tom William in his book, does mention that VSA can be applied to all time frames. Is it to be understood that, for eg in a 5mt chart we might have to go back further ? Will this not become counter productive ? Where should we begin and stop? I am still taking my 1st steps in trading as well as VSA , and my only intention is to learn and improve. Once again thank you all for your input. Regards, Omrudra

Hi, I have attempted to use VSA for the below chart. Any advice and corrections are most welcome ,in fact look forward to it. Point A: I took this bar as a sign of weakness, high vol, closing in the middle with next bar down. B:Test of supply? Negated by the next bar , point C- No demand? But the next bar( the one in yellow ellipse) has higher vol, narrow spread and close lower than C and low higher than the low of C.How do Interpret this? D: Sign of weakness. E: Sign of strength. But Im confused by the next bar ( in yellow ellipse). Is this no demand ? Is it to be ignored with strength in the back ground? F: No demand G: No demand H: What do I make of this? Chart 2, is a continuation, with some more analysis . In put on it appreciated. I do apologise if the charts are untidy, will strive to polish the latter charts. I feel I am going fundamentally wrong some where in my approach. All advice is appreciated. Good Trading!

Hi CandleWhisperer, Thanks a lot for the great analysis , it was very informative and did answer my questions. If your reply is any indication of the quality of people in this forum, I am extremely happy to be a part of it. I will definitely try to upload more charts with questions and my attempts at analysis. Good trading Omrudra

Hi all, I have been reading the posts in the forum for quite some time and have learned quite a bit. I am attempting to incorporate VSA into my trading. I still have tons to learn. I am attaching this mornings bund futures chart . I am confused by the rally at 9.40 ( around 80 ticks). I could not see any sign of strength in the back ground. Could some one point out some things I should have been watching for? I realise this must be a noobish question and that I still have to develop my fundamentals regarding VSA . But all answers are welcome. To moderators: I am not sure if I should be starting a new thread on this , please move delete if required. Thanks in advance. Omrudra