VSA Crock or Not 2

[VSA Crock or Not 2]

Yes sir, I,m on my way:)

[VSA Crock or Not 2]

I have spent the last 6 months working with Eiger on VSA chart reading[no TRADEGUIDER SOFTWARE] and can honestly state that once proficent at reading the BARS/ VOLUME the system works 95% of the time.

[Best Trading Platform for VSA]

Tradecenter.No charge for live feed.No stocks,just futres,Forex,Options.

[Topic Of The Month March, 2009]

I found this post on "Re: Pure VSA" interesting and have nominated it accordingly for "Topic Of The Month March, 2009"

[The Obama Deception]

Whatever:haha:I'm here for TRADING.Politics belongs elsewere.

Bye the way. Will be BPE.

[The Obama Deception]

Here go the BRAIN DEAD.Maybe,just maybe we have a President who really wants to do some good. But then you have the Limbaughs,Hannitys,Oreilly's, just a bunch of out of touch pompous BLOWHARDS.

[Do Courses Help?]

Find a course that works with a live feed.Static charts are great, looking at history,it's the right edge that makes the money. Find someone that will get you to working live.

[Tradestation Just Lost My Business... Looking for a New Platform/broker]

TRADECENTERLLC.[Open e- cry.]No charge for LIVE FEED.Competetive pricing.Great service[ask for DREW.I ave been using their paper trading platform for months for a small fee.Again no cost for live feed & their charting is pretty good.

[Do Courses Help?]

I've gone down this road.I believe you can gain a lot more insight with someone to bounce questions off.I spent a lot to work with a mentor?. 3 moving averages,etc. When i went live I was on my own.That's where I could have used some help.I find it difficult to grasp a lot of Wyckoff,VSA without some guidance. But do your research before you jump in.As everyone knows there are a zillion courses out there[just look at all the testimmonials]I wonder where the 90% losers are?

[Sandbox]

There was a link to a site that had a free course by Hank Pruden on Wyckoff.Anyone have that info?

[Price Action Only]

For those looking to cut thru the muck & mire, may I recommend Dbphoenix's book & his links to Wyckoff.Very informative & witty.`

[Combining VSA with Other Modalities]

Wouldn't mind looking over Db's, Brownsfan[to name just 2 that come to mind]shoulder.I'm sure it would shorten the learning curve.

[Combining VSA with Other Modalities]

I'm sure 95% of newbys have invested in course,tutorials,etc. & have found them to be less than advertised.I wonder though where 90% of the losers are?Just look at all the testimonials for the thousands of programs out there.I took the bait 2 years ago & am still searching.But as an article i just read said.It's takes more than 2 weeks, 6 months, 1 year to become a brain surgeon.So I figure minimum 3 years [unless you find the right mentor, program]to grasp the traders edge.But as Tom Williams said,if you learn to really be able to read a chart your half way there.

[Combining VSA with Other Modalities]

Only the 2 Wyckof modules[whatever that means] are $199.00

[Combining VSA with Other Modalities]

Tod Krueger's site is back up.Anyone have a take on his Wyckof DVD courses.Would they cut thru the fog?

[VSA : Crock or Not?]

:)Watched Manby's videos & most of his right edge next bar predictions were wrong.But no excuses were given [i say good for him] Why criticise VSA, If you like what it does go for it.I'm trying to get away from MA, MACD,STOCH.On paper trading worked for me.Not so good in realtime.But I don't critcise,obviously they work for some.

[[VSA] Volume Spread Analysis Part II]

Anyone interested Tod Kreugers web site Traders Code is up.

[VSA : Crock or Not?]

Well, I guess my search for the "Grail" continues.Back to 3 MA, Bol. Bands, Macd, Stochastics.

[VSA : Crock or Not?]

I believe there is a link on the VSA thread to Sebastian Manbys videos [on Elite trader site]

[[VSA] Volume Spread Analysis Part II]

Jeddi, thanks. Trying to get a handle on VSA,Wyckoff.

[[VSA] Volume Spread Analysis Part II]

Please see todays ES video. Thanks

 

The videos with discription is the way to go.As someone who has just opened the door to VSA.

[Learner Thread]

:)Sounds good.Had a fair amount of success using indicators,then went to inside bars & stochastics [Win at trading] Not very successful.But I believe the way to go is Wyckoff, VSA.

[[VSA] Volume Spread Analysis Part II]

:)Sledge, I see that you mentioned "bootcamp" in one of your posts.Can you enlighten me on this.Is it a course?

[Learner Thread]

ICI, To discribe what is going on with Charting & explaining is a big help for someone switching from indicators to Wyckoff.

keep up the post.Along with Dbphoenix,Blowfish,etc. I am starting to see the ebb & flow.

[Price Action Only]

PRICE ACTION,I am on the quest to rid myself of indicators.Since i have been trying a method using Stochastics & inside candles, with S/R, Double tops, Bottoms & Fib.Have not been as profitable as when i was using 3 MA, Bol. Bands, RSI, Macd.The impulse is to revert back & add indicators {of which I have,2 MA}.Has it been successful? No.So I am reading Wychofs book[ThanksDBPhoenix} & also have read Tom Williams insightful book on the Tradeguider site.If i could afford there program,as a novice it seems the way to go, I would .But $2995.00 is a bit much.