metalhead

Now, if you compare that to the HMA(8) based off of the regular chart, you will see that they are almost the same but in some cases the HMA(8) based off of the actual price will change slope quicker (as you would expect it to because it's not based on lagging HA data). In the attached screen shot, the first row of boxes shows the slope of the HMA(8) based off of actual price data and the second row of boxes shows the slope of the HMA(8) based off of Heikin-Ashi candles. This is the same chart as before so the data is the same.

Hi, am I allowed to bump this thread? I hope so. I never really liked HA candlesticks because what you're looking at isn't true price and therefore I always assumed it was pointless. This thread has shown a good way to see trends (albeit on HA candlesticks) by using an HMA(8) over the HA candlesticks. What you need to do in order to see exactly how much lag there is, rather than doing side-by-side comparison charts of HA vs. regular, is to do this instead: - Load your HA candlesticks as a study on your chart - Apply HMA(8) to the HA candlesticks - Color your main price chart based on the slope of the HMA(8) that has been applied to the HA candles. This will let you see in real time and with actual price data what is going on with regard to your trend-defining indicators on the HA candle sticks. In other words, where your main price chart changes color is where your HA slope is changing. Hopefully that made sense. I'm really tired right now so I hope I explained everything well. Here's a pic: edit - I can't believe I misspelled Heikin-Ashi in my pic. I even study Japanese so I shouldn't have gotten it wrong. Oops!

Hi. Sorry to bump this old thread but I've been reading this entire series of threads and am trying to follow along. I'm using SierraChart and have loaded the VWAP but I can't figure out how to get the SDs loaded. When I add the SD study and base it off of VWAP, I get new lines that are very close to the VWAP. I've attached a pic to show what I'm talking about. My options for the SD study are: Top Band Input Data Bottom Band Input Data Length Multiplication Factor Moving Average Type Any ideas on how to correctly set this (or code my own SD formula is this one is wrong) are appreciated. Thanks!

Hi, Has anyone been using these indicators successfully in their trading? Please share your experience. Thanks.