winnie

Hi Frank, Thank you for sharing ! it is very clear and you are so smart !:thumbs up:

Dear Frank, Do you have any idea in today 's market. Yesterday, I have strong feel that it will make new low first and high in afternoon. However today , I really don't have any idea. Just want to know how you think ? Thanks

Dear Frank, Thank you for your detail explanation .

Dear Frank, what conclusion will you draw for tomorrow ? Thanks for sharing your idea

Frank., it is great ! I have watch the market today and looking for your setup, A-D looking for low ! it is just happen. However, I would ask you , in actual trading, how do you enter the trade , as B, C,D period all make new low, in real time, how do we actually know which one are the final low for the morning period ? Do you try to catch the low ,everytime the 30 minutes bar make new low ? thanks.:pc guru:

In what way, do you think Alexander book is good ? Does it provide detail on how to enter and exit the trade ? Thanks

Dear Frank, Thanks for your detail ,clear and logical explain. Best wishes for profitable trading:applaud:

Dear Frank, Thank you for sharing your idea, it is great and sound. How long have you been trading ? Are you trade everyday ? I am trading my trading system and it is my first time to learn discreationary trading. Thanks again for your work

Dear Frank, Your book review is so great ! Thanks for your hard work. As a Market Profile trader, I would like to ask you in your example, do you need to wait for the Market Profile chart to shows a Excess before you short ? That mean do you need to wait for the F period complete before you go short ? However, if you do not wait for F period finish ? how do you know E period is an excess ? Thanks again for your kind work !

Does anyone have read the book by Alexander trading ? "PRACTICAL TRADING APPLICATIONS OF MARKET PROFILE" Any comment and new ideas on the book ? thanks

I use this tools to plot the MP http://www.pivotprofits.com/Tools/TPOChart/tabid/108/Default.aspx Hope this can help Thanks

Does anyone know how to plot Market Profile in Excel. I do not need real time Market Profile chart, just manual type in 30 minutes high/low to form the chart. I have use TPO chart calculator in a web site, it is great but it only plot one day Market profile chart. Thanks Winnie

DEAR JAMES, Thank you for your help. It makes thing very clear ! By the way ,do you know how to get the tape reading information you shows in your video ? I don't have TradeStation and use Interactive Brokers as a trading platform. Anyway you are very helpful Winnie

Dear sir, If Market Profile tell you the buyer is in control. Will you still sell in real time ? do we need to have a fix view on the market ?

Dear sir, Thanks for your reply. Now I am analysis the Market Profile after the market close and it give me the roadmap of which one has strong controlling. Like Tuesday, Monday's Market Profile tell me the buyer is in control. However I do not know how to trade in real time ? Where to buy ? Finally the anlaysis is works, it shows higher high on Tuesday. However I cannot win as I do not how to entry, I just sit there....

Dear sir, I am new to this web but find it has a lot of useful information. I have a few questions to ask : 1) I have learned Market profile in a few months, read all the books about it. However I do not know how to use it in real time trading. I notice that you mainly use its VAH and VAL to trade. Do you just use it ? How about Single print and POC ? In addition, do you need to watch the Market Profile develpement in real time ? 2) Are you a scalper ? What is your daily goal and how many trade you would need to take evey day ? 3) What is your basic trading methodolgy ? If you trade only Support and Resistance , why you need to do homework before market open ? I am sorry to bring you so much question THANKS