Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.
winnie
-
Content Count
141 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by winnie
-
I agree with you. Eiger has nothing to return. He is really helpful. If you do not like VSA or his method, just skip this and find method which you feel comfortable and no need to complaint him. Thanks
-
Dear all of you, Would anyone tell me what is mean by "Hidden Test " and "Shake Out " Bar ? Thanks
-
No Demand: A narrow range bar with volume less than the previous two bars that closes down from the previous bar. With the next bar down. Do you mean close up ? I have little confuse in this. thanks Winnie
-
How to define narrow range and wide range ? Is there any method to well define it ? Thanks Winnie
-
Dear Eiger, Beside this web and Tom 's book, is there any other source which I could learn more about volume spread analysis ? Thanks Winnie
-
I would like to ask you what kind of volume do you think it is good for a test. If volume is so big (bigger than average ?) , you will say there is still supply in it. Do you mean you need a very low volume (lower then average ?) ? How do you distinguish between a spring and a test ? They both seem to be a hammer pattern in candlestick chart. Thanks
-
Thank you for sharing with us. Would you show me one trade as an example on how you combine 30 minutes chart and 3 minutes chart to set up an entry and exit ? Where you place your stop ? Very tight stop ? Thanks
-
Dear Eiger, Thank for your hard work ! it is very helpful. I have a question on your chart. On Point B, you said that "Next bar is up but on fairly high volume indicating that there is still some supply in the market." Do you refer to the bar just next to B as next bar ? if the bar is up and have higher volume, why you said it still some supply in the market ? Could we know there is supply in a up bar instead of down bar ? Also what is "Hidden test " ? Anyway thanks
-
Dear all experts, When I use VSA in actual trading , I find it is very useful especially combine with Support/Resistance. However, how do we find out the support and resistance ? Any idea in finding it ? Sometimes , there are two many support and resistance and make near very price is S/R ? How do we select which one to use ? Thanks
-
Dear all experts, In looking for a no demand bar or no supply bar, beside volume do we need to consider the close of the bar . Do we need the close of the bar be lower than the middle point of the bar to confirm a no demand bar ? Thanks for all your kind help
-
How to know whether an up bar is a no demand bar or just take rest of a downtrend and then resume the downtrend ? For example, if we see a downtrend( or last bar is strong down bar with wide spread and big volume) and then an up bar with a lower volume than previous two bar, can we say that the bar is a no demand bar ? Thanks
-
Dear Eiger, According to your experience, when using VSA in trading. Would you only take the signal that is follow the higher time frame only ? For example, your higher frame trend is up, would you only take the long signal only and ignore the sell signal in lower time frame ? There seems to be so many signal in 5 minutes charts. Thanks for sharing
-
That mean you do not need to trade everyday ? I think professional trader need to trade everyday. Are you full time trader ? What do you do if you do not need to trade , do you still monitor the market at trading hours ?
-
Dear all VSA experts, In using VSA analysis, sometimes most of you using daily bar or weekly bar or even point and figures analysis and then you real time chart like 30 minutes or 60 minutes. Does this mean you use longer time frame to determine the buy and sell trend and then use intraday chart to confirm your entry ? Could anyone give one simple example how to combine long term time frame and real time to signal a trade ? Thanks
-
Could anyone tell me those bars are no demand bar or not ? Any things can be seem in this chart ? Thanks
-
Would anyone tell me where I could get the volume data (End of the day) in NYSE ? Is there any chart which could display the SPX bar chart and volume in the web ? Thanks
-
Dear Eiger , Thank you ! When you said the bar has no demand, do you mean the up bar's volume is lower than previous bar ? Or the volume is very low ? How do you definite very low volume ? Thanks
-
Dear Eiger, According to your experience, what product volume is used in trading E-mini S&P ? In your daily and weekly analysis , I see you use SPX and NYSE volume . Is is better than use E-Mini futures volume in daily and weekly analysis and use E-Mins S& P volume in intraday analysis ? Thanks
-
Dear Eiger, Thank for your work. It is very very useful. Would you tell me what is the meaning of : 1) S/D 2) T/R : Does it mean Top Reversal ? 3) B/R ; Bottom Reversal ? 4) T W/Supply Thanks
-
Dear all VSA expert , I have read the book "Master the markets" and I don't understand why the Smart money need to test the market before the uptrend finally move . Below is the passage from the book: "The best way to find out is to rapidly mark the prices down. This challenges any bears around to come out into the open and show their hand. The amount of volume (activity) of trading as the market is marked down will tell the professional how much selling there is. Low volume, or low trading activity, shows there is little selling on the mark-down . " How do they know the selling pressure is small when they mark down the price ? Thanks for all your kind help
-
Dear Eiger , Thank you for you kind effort to explain the VSA. However as you said that : "Very high volume on an up bar indicates supply is still present. One of the axioms of VSA is that markets do not like very high volume on up bars -- why? because supply is present and supply (selling) could swamp demand as professinals try to take the market higher." I do not understand that why high volume on an up bar indicate supply is great instead of demand is great ? Traditional , high volume on an up bar should be good for an uptrend . Thanks again for your kind help
-
Dear Eiger, Thank for your clear explanation on VSA. However, I would like to ask you : 1) On Bar 5, it is a down bar with lower volume than before, thus it reflects the selling pressure is not strong ? 2) on Bar 9 , it is an up bar with big volume, thus it reflects the demand is strong ? how do you know the supply is strong in this bar ? 3) what is mean by UpThrust ? it is same as key reversal bar ? 4) if you use this chart to trade, and you hold a short position , would you take profit in the big volume down bar in Bar 6 ? Sorry for so much information. Thanks for your time Winnie
-
Where I could find that book "The Undeclared Secrets that Drive the Stock Market" ? Thanks
-
Dear sir , In addition , would you use 5 minute chart for entry and stop ? I feel there is a lot of noise in 5 minutes chart before, but after looking at your chart and your explains, it seems to be very clear . Thanks
-
thanks for sharing things with us.It is clear ! However I would like to know where I could learn the terms like : stop volume, Top Reversal ...... I do not understand what it mean and how to find it out. Thanks for your time, it is really very helpful.