kuky969

it seems that cross of ema 33 is nice setup http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1269890585_32_UploadImage.png

Travers trade 3 entry is 1165 ??? out 1163 ??

today same kind of trade... break of ema33,increasing bid VB on last two bars , CDV is red, cci6 below zero line,cci45 very near of zero line ,both headed down I took just RTH trade http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1269448799_93_UploadImage.png

Electronics, Traverse THANK YOUU. Well at last. I wanted just arouse people to help each other and post in this thread.I hope at least partialy manage it. My basic style of trading is VSA and El order flow is nice for confirmation my analysis. And Market profile is new dimension of my trading. So please people post here and try help each other . Life is not very easy and very expensive (at least in my country) and every help is great. Electronics, God likes people as you and hope he will help you and your family.

I think nobody want post "secrets" about Electronics trading . I use this setup 1 .. aggressive short , entry into VA (blue line) ,break of ema33, bar has green VB but price go down ... something is bad price goes to ema99 and POC yesterday 2, 3 ..increase of green VB,break of POV yesterday and ema33 ,long on 3 bar cci6 must be above/below zero line and cci45 must be very near of zero line and nearly break it http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1269374041_75_UploadImage.png Exit is problem. Electronuc please can you post some exact example how you manage exit ...cci, CDV, VB ..???? please no generally babblement People that asked ELectronic question for examp. " what is not really clear to me, is how you time your entry," or "How do you read volume inside a bar? If you blow up a few bars and explain what you see," are very naive , EL will answer just generally. EL I am convinced than you will not answer my question here .Sorry no offense , anyway your blog was useful for me ,so I have to thanks for your efforts , but I can imagine how are unfulfilled some people. I dont understant one thing ,EL said that trading is art and not exact science , but I think art is not possible program in FloBot , so self-repugnant.

Fulcrum you mean this situation ??? http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1265379523_97_UploadImage.png Thank you

Please is somebody using Excel MP from ryker ??? could you please write exactly procedure how use it if I dont want use datafeed or terminal Bloomberg and no need auto update. I wan just daily market profile after close market. I have csv file 1 min data in required format ,I copied it to adresar Import but what next ???? Please can anybody help me ???

I am not sure what charts cmach123 looking for but some charts from just a few Eigers posts was demaged . I dont know now what exactly problem was, but I asked Soultrader and he answers me that is not possible restore this pictures. I dont know what number of posts have this problem , but just chart is not possible open.I estimate about 10 pictures of charts - no more.

Thetatreder thank you. I would like ask you to post some of your trade .It would be very useful for me. Thank.

Can we expect drop of market ????? ..daily chart 1 ...sellers,next 2 bars lower low ,lower high,lower close in increased volume 2 no demand 3 big sellers 4 big sellers (small spread and big volume as reaction on previously bar) 5 no demand 6 sellers -reverse next bar - yesterday- no demand so what happen today ??

Some similar trades from yesterday - I love this days and kind of trades A- small 1 tick dip below yesterdays low (bears trapped) and quick rejection or escape of price from this area --"spring" B-- strong bar C- test or no supplly ??? - simply in market is not enough of supply--- long and again reaction from D on this strong up move is on decreasing volume 1-- spring 2- rejection - break of minor TL 3-test of supply 4- confirmed --long And nice similar trade was on 3 min TF at 2.42 h. pm (chicago)-- green rectangle, but I didnt take it http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1245983203_19_UploadImage.png http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1245983282_52_UploadImage.png

Thecloser I sent you a private messages

Yes I would like ask same question In book in page 118 AL write "......when a bear trend or sideways market is corecting sideways or up,the first bar with a low below the low of the prior bar is a Low 1...." Sorry but market on figure 4,16 page 120 is bear or sideways ???, why he marks L1, L2 ......???

Eiger Thank you for examples ,I watched this spring in yesterdays ES but there was not test bar . Did you entry without test of supplly bar ???. Thank you.

I try find distribution in 1 or 4 h. TF chart. I simply trying to find wide spread down bars on very high volume ( peak of volume from a few last bars) and subsequently price didnt move back or move back very slowly on decreased volume and next quick down move on extra high volume bar. just my view. It is hardly see always on 1 h or 4 h. TF so I try change time frame to 2 hour. But often I simply dont see it. Often I try find very nice "end of rising market" on bigger TF.

small surprise from market:) Friday I started trading in afternoon ,and market was in chop ,very poor volume ,level 903 was peak of volume from thursday(for me support) and after stopping volume (1) next bar make higher high,close on same price as high of bar num. 1 , next bar (2) was test of supply , I had entry signal on 500 V chart after break high of test bar , so I almost push the button,but I told myself ........it has not potential of move ,volume is poor , so i didnt take trade and close the platform,switched off computer ..... so result is not bad ?? ...market is unpredictable , small lesson for me http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1243778229_55_UploadImage.png http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1243778377_97_UploadImage.png BACKGROUND http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1243779050_0_UploadImage.png

just my view on 1 h. ES ....or question ?? http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1243581982_98_UploadImage.png

Today trade background: 1 H - price was near of supplly line , in area yesterdays big supplly,yesterdays high, support is now resistence, trend is down http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1242333696_80_UploadImage.png 5 min: 1 ....supply 2..... price heading to demand line on higher volume ,I expected attempt for break demand line price make lower low , a bit breaks demand line 3 .....supply entry 4.... no demand after a bit break of demand line for exit - target i use VWAP(is not in picture) ....on 889 ,very nice exit http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1242334612_18_UploadImage.png timing of entry short : 500V chart http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1242334828_87_UploadImage.png MOST IMPORTANT IS PATIENCE AND WAIT FOR "BEST SETUP" .......I always keep in mind

Can we say that in accumulation area every dip of price is buying by pros ??? AND Can we say (vice versa) in distribution area if price a bit rise that every rise is selling by pros ???

OK I try to post some my ideas (despite my poor english) . Generally I can say that it is a little public sources ( books ,video files...) to quality learn VSA. Yes book Master the markets it is basic and is very good read it a few times or some chapters at least . But if somebody wait for exact patterns for entry and for exit trade ,will be disappointed. Book are about basic principles . So question is where to start as pure greenhorn in VSA . My opinion is : ( in order) 1.. first .... very good learn to determine SR levels in market , in particular 15 or 60 min TF. This thred http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/f131/dbs-cajas-famosas-3882.html helped me . But in TL or any traders servers are other threads about SR levels. Ofcourse practice in real charts. ( I trade ES 5 min and determine SR on 1h and 300000 volume TF) 2 ... next ... I read almost all threads in Wyckoff forum ( basic of VSA is Wyckoff) and study all Wyckoff sources ,that you can find in this thread ( supplly–,demand , effort- result ,waves.....) Thank to DbPhoenix . 3 ..... Very important was everything what I consider as important for me put down and make my „own Wyckoff book“ . This book I repeatedly read ( in evening when child gone to bed,or in bath....) As time goes ,you read this book less and less because some capitols you learn by heart. 4 ...next I started read Master the markets ( and ofcourse continue with make a notes). You will learn a lot surprising thing. 5 Start read thread Volume spread analysis part I .....III , as the time goes you find some users that posts are very useful (thank you Eiger and other contributors) and I started make another „my own books“ with charts and posts ( in this time has more than 200 pages in officeWord) 6 Every day I watched live market (ES),tried determine background, SR levels and I wanted to see in market what I study in theory. I started to try find my own setups to entry in market, I prepared exact rules to exit trade . In threads you can find some setups for timing when entry in market , but I think it is needed too find others your own setups and gain confidence in. This take a long screen time and watching price action and volume on significant SR levels. BEST IS TO HAVE GOOD VSA MENTOR AND TRADE LIVE WITH HIM . Few people have this good fortune. But we can be lucky because Eiger and some contributors share with us a lot thoughts and examples,that I think is impossible get in other study sources. Important for every day: ---prepare list of things that I have to do before start market ---read your notes ---- and repeat,repeat ,repeat without end

Hi Mantra Yes I have same problem ,yesterdays afternoon uptrend on ES 5 min didnt give me any substantial VSA signal to entry long . I just waited when it rebounce from some resistence and give me signal short. I was very surprised that ES regain all losses in afternoon. Eiger did you make some trade ???

Yes but if I can write my personal opinion,no offence,this thread in FF has poor quality compared with TL threads . People there always try invent some magic study and pure VSA posts are just from a few traders,maybe just from one nick: "malcolmb". He is trading forex and his posts are very useful.

Eiger thank you very much for your free lesson. It is excellent .

I would like ask Eiger ,what do you think about it. ?? It is chart 5 min ES yesterday. http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1241665291_84_UploadImage.png After spring (S) bar 12,30 -- 12,35 h. I looked for test bar but I didnt find, so I didnt take long trade. It is chart 5 min ES yesterday too,but every bar starts 9,37 -- 9,42,--- 9,47 h....... http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1241665703_93_UploadImage.png Here I see test (T) in bar 12,37-12,42h. What is your opininion. It is good take long trade after this test bar ??? Thank you

as regards volume in forex. Esignal has very reliable data feed "GTIS forex" with data from 300+ big banks and financial company that is trading. Check web side. In forexfactory is one trader that trade forex a few years just using VSA and it seems he is very good .I watch his posts just one week and his expectation in market very often are truth.